1 of Infinity: You'll get 10 points....Are you Sherry's Detectives?

Question

Sherry's Detective are geniuses. My wife is looking for her long lost detectives. IF your are one then you'll get 10 points. But as a proof, answer this riddle:

On a murder scene (a bar room) were three people. There was a carpenter, a farmer, a lawyer. Dead on the floor was the waitress. And you, as the detective, knew that the murderer is inside the room. You successfully caught him, and you were promoted as Senior Detective.

Who was the murderer and how did you know that it was him?

First to answer correctly gets 10 points and be recognized as one of Sherry's Detectives.

I would take note of the answers so you won't get far if you use the "EDIT cheat"

Good luck!

Answer 1

The Lawyer - They good at telling lies!

So uphold the Law here

Ok, i won't erase my first answer because i admit i edit it...

After a long thinking and guessing, i guess my first answer was wrong, so here's my next ans...

The carpenter is the murderer because on the murder scene were three people, the carpenter was in the the room means he had left, so leaving three people a farmer, a lawyer and the dead waitress... Maybe the story goes like when the carpenter killed the waitress, he left.. So he was in the room and left. And the farmer who found the dead waitress hired a lawyer to prove his innocence... So beside the three people in the bar room, the carpenter was in the room. And he's the murderer!

Answer 2

farmer

Answer 3

farmer coz the waitress didnt get him the chicken? or she got the chicken? or something?

Answer 4

The carpenter... because she was hammered!

Answer 5

Lawyer, because it was a "bar" room?

Answer 6

the lawyer, because it's a "bar" room

Answer 7

I'm guess out of the lawyer, carpenter and farmer, 2 were women and only one was a man?  So cos I knew it was a man, it was whichever one was... a man.

Answer 8

The murderer is the farmer. It is because the farmer is the only person in the room that knows how to kill a living thing, like chicken or pigs or ducks, for their meat. He's the only one experienced in dealing with the death of something living.

Answer 9

the farmer is the killer. you are the lawyer,there "was" a carpenter.was being past tense which means the carpenter is dead,which also means it is the waitress . since you are the lawyer and the carpenter/waitress is dead that only leaves the farmer to do the killing.then  you did such a good job you were promoted.

Answer 10

I think it's the carpenter because he's the only one who has several deadly tools that are capable of killing somebody.  

Answer 11

We all know that lawyers 's***w' everyone, so the lawyer...!

But where was the barman?

Answer 12

the barman. It's in a bar, and there's the waitress (dead) and 3 customers.....

Answer 13

What the H*LL is a farmer or a carpenter doing at a bar?

i say lawyer because i can.