2006 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Limited or 2008 Subaru Impreza 2.5i Premium

Question

Automatic Legacy is $18,000

Manual Impreza is $19,000

I live in the snow... My father owns a 2002 Legacy and I have yet to drive a car that corners as well (So I lean towards the Legacy).

I don't want a turbo charged engine. Been there, done that.

Which one is a better deal and which one would you buy?

Answer 1

Hey Soggy - see you took my advice on the Subaru..... - Legacy all the way for me.

Answer 2

They are pretty different size wise so it might depend on your needs.  They both use a pretty much the identical engine and drive train.  I always say if budget allows, go with the newer car because there is always risk buying used but the newer the car the lower the risk.  With the 08 you get 2 years more warranty than the 06(approximately).

Answer 3

They may have the same engine and drive train, but they drive a lot different! The legacy would be my choice, the 5 speed tranny with sportshift is freaking smooth as silk. Plus since the Legacy is used, I would offer 15500 for it. Considering they got the 08  special editions for 16995 out here, I would bet they would take 15k for the '06. If not, tell them you will take the 08 SE Legacy. Might not have heated seats or leather, but still a great car(its what I bought!).