300 vs Lord of the Rings?

Question

Who wins in battle? The Riders of Rohan from LOTR or the Spartans from the movie 300?

Answer 1

Spartans from 300...

Answer 2

spartains have nothing against the Lord of the ring warriors.

all they have is brute force, no strategy.

Answer 3

As they say in the housing business: location, location, location...

In the open grasslands of the Mark, the Spartans are toast.

Put them in a narrow pass, or dug-in in ruins, and cavalry becomes impotent.

That was one of the travesty moments in the LotR film: (not in the book), Faramir and the Minas Tirith cavalry being sent to charge emplaced Orc infantry.

Answer 4

Wrong category. But I just had to say my piece:

The Rohrrim (or the Riders of Rohan) won the battle at Helm's Deep and Gondor. They had a magnificent victory and also, when all 300 die, don't you think that's a bit defeating the purpose? Unless you're talking about the very end.

LuthienT

Answer 5

The Spartans.

Answer 6

Shouldn't this question be under Movie catagory...

Oh well, I say maybe Spartans, their more skilled in many ways compared to the riders of Rohan (they were just going with the flow instead of thinking a battle plan.)

Answer 7

Spartans. That's the first movie that made me cry! Especially when Leonidas said, "My queen...my wife...my love." I cried and my cousin laughed! lol.

Shouldn't this be in the Movies category?