6N's! Shane Williams got the player of the Tournament award then, 2nd Sergio Parisse, Ryan Jones coming 3rd!

Question

Do you agree with this result?

I think it was for gone conclusion myself as far as Shane was concerned!

http://www.rbs6nations.com/en/10525.php?PHPSESSID=f103c0cd086376a0d9dd785d0fe257ee

Answer 1

it was always going to be Shane as player of the tournament with his try record.And Parisse always plays a good game, although i think 3rd place had a few contenders.

  In other aspects, what does everyone think of WIlkinson? Time to bow out after breaking the all time points record?Ciprianni looks like he is more than capable at 10.

  And to finish, i must say im gutted at the way Scotland played, as we have a great squad on paper, but we just cant produce.

  Although Mike Blair and Strokosch both had a good tournament.

Answer 2

Agree with Shane. Martyn Williams should have been up in the places though.

Answer 3

I'd have thought the top 22 Would have been the Welsh Squad !!

Nugget,Wyn Jones,Gough,Phillips  could / SHOULD have ALL been there

Answer 4

before the last game I thought that Lee Byrne may have won it but after Shane's try to beat France he deserved it. Martyn Williams also had an outstanding tournament. Outside of Wales, no one was consistant apart from the Italian pack so Parrisse and Castogiovani both deserve a mention.

Answer 5

Yes I do definitely! Shane more than deserved it ,  he was outstanding! Parisse is also a brilliant player and Ryan, I think had a fantastic 6 nations. I also feel that he is one of the best captains we have had in a long time!

Answer 6

for me parisse was player of the tournament with castrogiovanni and ryan jones 2nd and 3rd respectively

Answer 7

No ....Martin Williams should have got second place!

Answer 8

Shane Williams was always going to win, and rightly so.  As for 2nd and 3rd i'm not really sure because theres no one else that stands out in my mind as having had a great tournament

Answer 9

about right.

Answer 10

I'd agree with Shane bach getting player of the tournament, but I would have thought that old ''Nugget'' Martin Williams would have been in the top 3. He had an absolute belter of a tournament. It was genius of Warren Gatland to get him out of retirement! Llongyfarchiadau Shane Williams!!

Answer 11

i would have put ian gough in there somewhere. he is the unsung hero of the welsh side

Answer 12

Actually, no I don't :-( I think that others have been more consistent, Nugget for one has played a blinder all tourny, as has Goughie.