AFL: kouta or buckley or neitz whose best?

Question

i mean overall like rating them now whose number 1

Answer 1

kouta was the better player

Answer 2

Buckley for sure, and not just because I'm biased.

Kouta was good at the peak of his career, but not for very long.

Neitz was only seen as such a good player because he was one of Melbourne's only stars when he played.

Bucks won a Brownlow, countless Copelands, and so many other things.

Answer 3

Kouta.

Buckley left brisbane in search of a premiship and then brisbane won threee and he won NONE!

Neitz is up their with kouta but not quite better.

Answer 4

all different players

Answer 5

Kouta. all the way

Answer 6

ohhh. hard question.

i'd have to say bucks. but kouta came close. sorry neitza.

Answer 7

Kouta the Gladiator!!

Though I think Neitz actually spent more time bein an on field captain rather than a bench captain..

Answer 8

Buckley is my number 1 he was a extremely skillful player and he was a great leader Kouta was great in his peak and also was Neitz but Buckley was consistanant his whole career its a shame he never won a Premiership and im a North Melb Supporter bad luck all the Hawks fans better luck next time

Answer 9

kouta

i want to have his baby

Answer 10

Buckley is a better commentator and he was probably a better player too. Did Neitz or Kouta win a Brownlow? I don't think they did....

Buckley was more consistant as a player over a longer period of time however Kouta was very exciting in his prime! Neitz was more of a quiet achiever.