Adopting a third dog?

Question

Alright, so we have two dogs a husky and a great dane that get along perfectly and we are the type of people that get their animals from the shelter. There is an english setter that is almost out of time at our local shelter and we want to adopt her.

One problem... she's dog aggressive with dogs that live in the same house with her. While I have been trained to deal with this and know many ways to prevent fighting and trouble I am curious if anyone else has ever had this problem.

She is a gorgeous dog that just needs to reassurance and some TLC. We want to give her that... and have a happy health pack.

Has anyone ever had a good outcome with this type of situation?

Answer 1

If the dog is dog aggressive with other animals in the household, then getting her is a terrible idea.  She obviously has problems with other pets in the household, so bringing her into your home with two dogs already, would be very stressful for her.  Try and find someone else to adopt her who have no other pets in their home.  She will not be happy and neither will you or your other two dogs.  It's a wonderful thought, but sometimes, circumstances beyond your control prohibit you from doing what you want to do.  

Answer 2

several years ago, I was put in much the same position, only with much smaller dogs. Whatever you do, the dogs already in the house will feel a little "invaded". If you can keep them somewhat separate, and introduce them slowly I think it will work out fine. One thing you didn't mention is what the dogs ages are, that could make some difference-a playful puppy may annoy an older dog. Since you have training in the matter, follow your heart and head, and don't forget to have a chat with your vet. God Bless You for rescuing "shelter dogs! You are truly an angel! You will be in my prayers.

Answer 3

You have it good with 2 dogs that get along and every one loves everyone.  You have it good.  Don't mess it up.  You will have problems.  While it is admirable that you want to save this dog unless you want one of your beloved dogs to get killed or hurt and lots of problems, forget about it.  The dog is agressive with other dogs, let it go.  You can't change that.....she's an animal.