Adrian Peterson Trade?

Question

I have Adrian Peterson, and was recently offered Larry Johnson and Willis McGahee for him. Should i do it and why, thanks!

Answer 1

I would ask for more, you're giving up a guy who, if he stays healthy, could be the best fantasy player this year.  I wouldn't trade A.P. unless I was getting back equal value and in this case I don't think you are.

Answer 2

With what information your giving me, I would say no.

But I can't make an educated answer, because I don't know what you have for other RBs, or QB or WR.

If they are all weak besides Peterson, then trade.

If they are good RBs, don't and keep Peterson.

Hard for me to say.

Answer 3

no hes a super star  he'll get you plenty of points bad idea

Answer 4

It depends on How good your other RBs are....I you already have another good running back than no. But if your backup running back sucks...than probably yes for depth.

Answer 5

I suppose it depends on who your other RB is. If you picked a RB in round 2 or 3 then you should be pretty solid in that regard. IMO, both Johnson and McGahee are unpredictable and unreliable. Whereas AP could have a standout year and probably will. On the other hand, if your number 2 RB is iffy, you can't deny the depth you'll have at RB with a 2 for 1 deal. I don't envy your decision but if your number 2 is ok already then decline this trade. If you're weak at RB beyond AP, then yes. Good luck.  I just saw the 8-man league thing at that makes me assume that you are solid at RB2 (you'd almost have to be). Decline the trade.

Answer 6

No.

AP > Larry Johnson + McGahee

Adrian Peterson - Best guaranteed production (Minnesota has no quarterback, bad wide receivers, and a good offensive line, he will be producing day-in & day-out)

LJ - Going downhill, think Shaun Alexander with a gentler slope, and

McGahee - Ravens have no quarterback, bad wide receivers, and a very bad offensive line, defenses will exploit it and stack the line to shut down McGahee, the only hope for the Ravens.

Answer 7

No, your trading a great RB away for two good but unpredictable RBs

Answer 8

no because u have a talented rb for not so talnetd players

now answer mine

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;...

Answer 9

You shouldn't do it. AP is a great rb. LJ and McGahee are getting old. AP will get more carries. LJ has to compete with Bowe and Gonzalez to get the ball. McGahee has to compete with Ray Rice to get carries. AP has to compete against Taylor and Berrian. That's not a lot of competition.