Advice on trade? I give McNabb, Chad Johnson, and Westbrook - I get Brady, Fitzgerald and Reggie Bush.?

Question

I'm thinking of pulling the trigger on this one but I'd like some opinions on it from all of you experts out there. My team is:

QB: McNabb, Schaub

RB: Westbrook, Lewis, Turner, Forte, McAllister

WR: Johnson, Wayne, Galloway, Burleson

TE: Miller

D: Jags

We have QBs for 25yds=1pt, TD=4

RBs - 10yds=1pt, TD=6

WRs - 10yds=1pt, TD=6

My thinking is that my severe upgrade at QB and a more consistent receiver in Fitz makes this a good idea.

Thanks for the input!

Answer 1

Let's break it down

McNabb for Brady = +

Johnson for Fitz = =

Westbrook for Bush (who's gonna stink) = -

Thus u only get brady and loose a RB..the WR doesnt really matter becuase they're equal and both have competition in Boldin and TJ (who i just traded for!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!)

i would do the deal beuase its brady but its no big thing if u reject...

GO WITH DA GUT

Answer 2

keep westbrook trade the other 2

Answer 3

Brady and Fitz are an upgrade over McNabb and CJ for sure. Bush is a big downgrade from Westy, but given the points you will generate from Brady alone. I would do that trade in a heartbeat

Answer 4

Chad Johnson = Fitzgerald

McNabb < Brady

Westbrook > Bush

Is giving up Westbrook worth Brady?  

Answer 5

Hey man you shouldnt even need help with that McNabb-Brady Brady wins by a land slide. Johnson-Fitzgerald Fitzgerald because not only do i think he is better but johnson has a bad ankle and a bad attitude so palmer probably wont get him the ball as much. Westbrook-Bush...westbrook is on the decline so as long as bush stays healthy bush wins that one

so in my opinion you win 3-0

Answer 6

Dont Do It!!!!

you single handly have phillys offense and Chad Johnson will do much better than larry fitz due to the fact that he actually has some1 that can throw him the ball... i would not proceed with this trade, if your smart.