After a very shameful loss to pakistan, shoud dhoni resign from his captaincy?

Question

during dravid's period we clinched the trophy twice against pakistan,but now we r lost, so should dhoni resign from captiancy?

Answer 1

I think it would be a good idea to take Yuvi or Sehwag an ODI captain; keeping Dhoni for T20.

He needs to mature.

Answer 2

What?

No...If every captain resigned because they lost, we'd see teams finding it hard to know how to go about their cricket.

Every captain has their own way of leading the team... If the captain keeps getting changed your just going to ruin the team as well...

You can't keep changing captains because in this match it looked like Dhoni wasn't a good captain or for whatever reason you are question his captaincy for. He stuck by those young players against australia and India were triumphant, i think it's time someone stuck by Dhoni.

Answer 3

the loss was  hard but it was well fought.

pak's 140 run loss was humiliating.

dravid is an indian cricket legend and his contributions in the past are second to none but in today's game, he is obsolete. today's game requires hard hitting fast scorers and david ain't it.

nalakafairy is an idiot.

Answer 4

no

Answer 5

come on............we win or lose..it has to be faced. i think so that captains are pressurized a lot if they lose one match. as an indian i also felt very bad, but it is the lows and highs of the game. Punter was also put under pressure after he lost the Ashes and when his team lost the 3rd test against India. The criticizers should also think of what achievments they have done in the past. it is just ridiculous.

Answer 6

WAT ?one bad match doesn't mean a person has to resign.how about when we won the t20 world cup , the match where we won for 140 runs against Pakistan.If a person had to resign after every lost match then we would more than 11 players in a team.

Answer 7

I don't think he will quit he is one of the most Shameless cricketer in the world next to Harbhajan Singh. Yuvraj Singh should have been captain at the first place. BCCI elects captain on their popularity bases

Answer 8

or Indian team...captaincy is a HOT SEAT coz,whenever a player takes up Captaincy,his perfomence was affected..Many experienced players like Ganguly,Dravid,Sachin failed Indiavisually when they were appointed as Captains.

as v hav seen in IPL yuvraj's was under pressure bcoz of captaincy and thus his batting was affected..

CRYSTAL - u b____,u suck!!

Answer 9

In a way ,..YES in fact,...all rounder Yuvaraj Sing is most suited for Indian captain in  ODI team ~

and he is more experienced than M.S.Dhoni..actually mahi is not matured enough yet to lead team India ,..When referring to last year world cup.// losing to Bangladesh & Pakistan is little ,...embarrassing,.... as for the Asian cricket giants Indians hate lose to them,...(BANGLADESH & PAKISTAN)

Answer 10

In this match ;which won By PAKISTAN ,...we saw many wrong decisions were  taken by  this in -experienced Skipper, People are giving the reasons for India's defeats and all of them were a result of poor captaincy!!!!!!!!

how about when we they  the t20 world cup ,it was a fluke cuz Miss-bah just miss-hit the ball , if not pakistan would have been the champs!!!

Answer 11

Doni should resign from his captaincy

Answer 12

No,Dhoni is still a great captain.Dhoni made Indian cricket team to win the Twenty 20 World Cup.

Answer 13

If Captains have to resign after every loss, Captains of Indian team will last only few matches, which will adversely affect the progress of team.  Demand for resignation of captain should come only if the team looses matches consistently.

Answer 14

nonsense................................... that india under m.s. defeated pakistan shamefully..........................khel me har jeet to hoti rahti hai dada

Answer 15

During Dravid's Period We Were Trashed In 2007 World Cup By Bangladesh and Sri Lanka Still Dravid Retained His Captiancy Then Why after One loss Dhoni Should Resign?

Answer 16

In the match there were many wrong decision taken by the captain, People are giving the reasons for India's defeats and all of them were a result of poor captaincy, it was the time when he had to make difficult decision and he failed , like coming late to bat , playing with 4 bowlers , no RPsingh etc., If there is more experienced player in the team then he should be given this responsibility. But I do believe that he should be given another chance

Answer 17

India Wins A Tri-Series In Australia And Everyone Loves Him And Just Because He Lost One Match Everyone's Jumping On Neck.