All Blacks No.10? Knockout stage?

Question

Who should it be (between Carter and Evans)

Carter : Career, 1st option, current form, injury cloud.

Evans: Career, 2nd option, RWC Form(18/20), Versatility, Current form

Answer 1

Should be Carter -more experience but I would start Evans at

Fullback. Not a fan of MacDonald.

Evans offers more in attack and with the boot and he defends well.

Answer 2

Carter without a doubt mate!!

Do I even have to justify my answer???

He's the best player in the world and has simply never played a bad game. A bad game from Carter is an average to good game for anybody else.

Evan's has looked good but it has been against very weak opposition. He also lacks experience. Everyone keeps saying "he is in good form" or "he hasn't played in any big tests so how can you say he won't measure up?". That is exactly why he shouldn't be starting at no.10. He is an unknown at the top level. Carter is a superstar and will certainly rise to the occasion.

Evan's is a great player and it is good to see him on the bench. He is from my club (GO BAYS!!), great bloke to.

Answer 3

Nick Evans is one of my favourite players, but is suspect on defence.

If he could tackle theres no doubt he would be our first choice fullback.

Carter = pure Class

Answer 4

Oh he's had his bad games, Jonboy. I have seen Carter fold dismally under pressure in a Super 14 game at Loftus. He was pathetic.