Question:

All Time Black Team (Read On)?

by  |  earlier

0 LIKES UnLike

The greatest team of black players. Mine

C: Roy Campanella

1B: Willie Stargel

2B: Joe Morgan

3B: Jackie Robinson

SS: Ernie Banks

LF: Barry Bonds

CF: Willie Mays

RF: Hank Aaron

SP: Satchel Paige

SP: Bob Gibson

SP: Don Newcombee

SP: Fergie Jenkins

SP: Dwight Gooden

I know Jackie Robinson played mainly at 2nd and 1st but he did play some 3rd base

CL: Lee Smith

 Tags:

   Report

9 ANSWERS


  1. If we are talking all-time and not just major leagues, I would put Josh Gibson in at catcher, Oscar Charleston in left and Cool Papa Bell as a back-up outfielder, and I would replace Newcombe with Double Duty Radcliff.

    Jackie actually had fantastic numbers defensively at third.


  2. A little too racists? I agree pretty much, but that I'd take Willie McCovey over Stargell anyday.. I mean, cmon man. And take that juicer Bonds out


  3. Just to put a sock in the morons calling you a racist, Do the all-French team, the all Dominican team, the all Canadian team etc.

    There are a LOT of better choices at 3rd than Robinson.

    Campanella was really Cuban and doesnt count.

    I really hate these types of lists, far too subjective and far too many variables, and I hate separating things by race or origin, but I just had to come to your defense. I also hate people who arent racist being called racist.

  4. That's discriminatory.  

  5. SS: Ozzie Smith

  6. great job!!!

    BEST ANSWER ME!!!

  7. I did a good job w/this list I think. I posted this once and it got reported so I posted w/backup. I won't give myself a best answer though.

    T-Mac. I agree how could I forget McCovey. I probally should take out Bons and put in

    A: Ken Griffey Jr.

    B. Josh Gibson

    C. Rickey Henderson

    As for SS. I like Smith but Banks was a way better player

  8. yeah good list. i cant argue with that.  

  9. Yes, good job, go ahead and give yourself best answer but I'd put Dave Stewart instead of Satchel Paige.  Paige really has no verfiable records.

Question Stats

Latest activity: earlier.
This question has 9 answers.

BECOME A GUIDE

Share your knowledge and help people by answering questions.