All Time Hockey Fights?? Who would Win??

Question

Bracket 1

1. Bob Probert

8. George Parros

2. Stu Grimson

7. Tie Domi

3. Joey Kocur

6. Troy Crowder

4. Marty McSorely

5. Georges Laraque

Bracket 2

1. Gordie Howe

8. Donald Brashear

2. Dave Brown

7. Chris Simon

3. Craig Coxe

6. Jim Cummins

4. Craig Berube

5. Darren McCarty

Answer 1

My answers are based off of A. fighters in their prime B.strictly fights with no tangibles involved

Bracket 1

1 Probert

7 Domi

3 Kokur

4 McSorley

Bracket 2

1 Howe

2 Brown

3 vs 6 not sure on this one

4 Berube

Answer 2

Probert

Grimson

Crowder

Laraque

Brashear

Simon

Cummins

McCarty

Answer 3

1 Bob Probert

7 Tie Domi                  

1 Bob Probert

                                                                    

3 Joey Kocur            

5 Georges Laraque

5 Georges Laraque

1 Bob Probert

5 Georges Laraque

Bracket 2

3 Craig Coxe                

8 Donald Brasher

8 Donald Brasher

                                  

4 Craig Berube

7 Chris Simon

7 Chris Simon

Finals

                                  

George Laraque            

Donald Brasher

Winner

George Laraque

Answer 4

Bob Probert

Stu Grimson

Joey Kocur

(GO BRUISE BROTHERS)

Georges Laraque

Donald Brashear

Dave Brown

Jim Cummins

Craig Berube

Answer 5

Where's Todd Bertuzzi? Oh, so smahing someone's skull in doesn'tprove toughness nowadays? jeez, wht has the world come to? jk

Answer 6

Bracket 1

1. Bob Probert

2. Stu Grimson

3. Joey Kocur

4. Marty McSorely

Bracket 2

1. Mr. Hockey

7. Chris Simon

6. Jim Cummins

5. Darren Mac

Round 2

Bracket 1

Bob Probert over McSorley

Joe Kocur over Grimson

Both matches very close

Bracket 2

Gordie Howe over Darren McCarty (more fighting in Gordie's day, he has the experience factor)

Jim Cummins over Simon

Gordie Howe and Bob Probert in the finals.

I have to go with Bob Probert.  He is the greatest fighter of all time.  Both former Red Wings, both bad asses.

And yeah why no Dave "Tiger" Williams?

Answer 7

Grimson over Laraque in Bracket One

Howe over Cummins in Bracket Two

Grimson vs. Howe

AND Grimson takes it all. GO GRIM REAPER!

Answer 8

Probert vs. mccarty...unless chris simon gets to use his skate to try and slash someone, in which case i would choose him over mccarty...there are some sweet fight montages of Probert vs. domi on youtube - you should check em out.

Answer 9

Bracket 1

1. bob probert

7. tie domi

3. joey kocur

4. marty mcSorley

bracket 2

1. gordie howe

2. dave brown

6. jim cummins

5. darren McCarty

Answer 10

Tiger williams isn't in it, so I refuse to answer.

Answer 11

Probert

Domi with the upset

Kocur

Laraque after an epic battle

Howe after toying with the kid

Brown

Cummins after Coxe wears down

McCarty