American Idol New Judge!!?

Question

OMG,their is gonna be a new judege on american idol and her name is Kara DioGuardi.I think the idea is stupid!!!What do u think!?

Answer 1

????!!!!!???????!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!?!?!?!?!?... holy c**p this is news 2 me! ive been a big fan of american idol 4 the past couple of years and this i do not like. the balance with all the judges was perfect. simon was the mean 1 who was rude but always right. paula was the nice 1 that made light out of everyones perfomance. randy was the rock of the 3 judges and kept paula and simon from killing each other and he was the 1 that was the most fair . this new judge has nothing new to bring to the show and will affect the balance of the show. sorry kara, but i think a differrent tv show is better for you.

Answer 2

It is true. Kara DioGuardi will be the fourth judge on American Idol this season. Here is some info I found on google.But i really don't think they need another judge.

Grammy-nominated songwriter Kara DioGuardi, will provide a little "girl power" to the judging panel according to a Fox executive.

Adding a fourth judge is no a novel idea according to the show's executive producer Cecile Frot-Coutaz.

"We had originally intended for American Idol to have four judges," she said.

DioGuardio has written songs recorded by Kelly Clarkson, Christina Aguilera, Gwen Stefani, Celine Dion, Faith Hill, Carrie Underwood and Pink.

What do you think about adding a fourth judge to the mix? Will the chemistry be negatively affected. Will this give Paula less of an opportunity to make a fool of herself? We'll find out when the show debuts on Fox in January.

Answer 3

I personally hate the idea. The other three judges have been together for 7 seasons now and have great chemistry. There's absolutely no reason for a fourth judge, it's just going to take more time away from the actual contestants so that we can listen to the pointless comments of the judges that no one ever listens to anyway. I remember one season I think it was season two they had a guest judge for every show and I hated that too, I like it better with just Randy, Paula and Simon.

Answer 4

I think we should give her a chance and see what she brings to Amer. Idol before we jump all over her.  It's a done deal - so let's see what'll happen.  I love the show....and am satisfied with the 3 judges.  Guess they just want to try something new.

Answer 5

I think it's a good idea I hope the judge is replacing Simon because he is so mean and always has something rude to say to the contestants no matter what it is.

Answer 6

I liked the old judges, they don't need a new one! The show was already amazing! The new judge idea is stupid.