An honest assessment of the celtic team..?

Question

boruc ..carrying some excess weight..looks at least 2 stone heavier than when he joined .

wilson ...i feel sorry for him dumped at left back and looks very uncomfortable.like rangers first goal when cousin`s roasted him.

mcmanus and caldwell talk a good game but caldwell the pair are one dimensional head the ball or hoof the ball.

hinkell ..well the least said about him the better..caddis should be playing there.

hartley..legs have gone brown headless chicken

naka..only turns up for set pieces .

robson..one lucky bhoy he only gets a game cos of the S***e celtic have in there.

voh...when was the last time you saw this guy win a sprint.. a big plodder..check his passport no way is he dutch same dna as konterman....

maloney the saviour ..he he he he

Answer 1

with a good win under their belt u still want to talk about the hoops or should that be hoopless

Answer 2

BORUC....totally useless yesterday

WILSON..honest hardworking player,should have stopped cousin

MC MANUS,..booked early descent game

CALDWELL..tries his best,but its not good enough..

HINKELL...caddis is much better,faster in this roll,waste of money

MCGEADY..poor game,predictable

HARTLEY..honest player,always gives 100 %

BROWN..cant figure the boy out at all.problems last season,carried  to this season.poor form,waste of money

NAKAMURA..lightweight,never runs set piece luxury

MALONEY,full of trickery playing to deep

SAMARAS..better than JVOH,with his movement,looked good but playing to deep

ROBSON...should have started another honest hard player

JVOH..should be fined by club,being on the park ,hed to fa anyway  

Answer 3

Boruc - decent keeper, hyped up but one bad game doesnt mean hes pish

Wilson ...being played out of position, good young scottish talent

Mcmanus and Caldwell - McManuns is a decent centre half (for a jags fan) and Caldwell is c**p, Loovens will replace him

Hinkel - i said when he signed that he wasnt very good and you lot laughed at me, whos laughing now???

Hartley - too old

Brown - cant go forward as theres no-one to support him, got the attitude, just needs the team-mates

Nakamura - cant get to grips with our physical game

Robson - similar attitude to brown, needs to be a starter to reap the benefits from him

VOH - too slow, too pish

Maloney - Good utility player for celtic, has the pace no-one else has

McGeady - Thinks he is better than he really is

Answer 4

What about Samaras?

I think hes got good individual skill knows how to beat a defender and can finish but I think hes a bit weak for his size. What do you think?

Answer 5

mince

Answer 6

don't forget samaras man city fans could not stop laughing when he went to celtic and after yesterday i still cant stop laughing either

Answer 7

Based on one game?

Ok Struthie - i would do an assessment of the Rangers team but i cant be arsed writing it all out - hungover from drowning my sorrows yesterday,lol!

Answer 8

well as someone pointed out to me today.

If Boruc is having marital problem then this would be a perfect time for him to come out of that closet he's hiding in.

Answer 9

An honest opinion, based on last season and this thus far, not one game (which I want to forget ASAP)

Boruc- Top class, pish poor yesterday but one game doesn't make him a bad player.

Wilson- decent squad player, should never be a regular starter, I do feel sorry for him having to play LB as he clearly is not comfortable there.

Hinkel- very inconsistent, would give Caddis a chance and see whether he can consistently do it. Caddis has great potential but can only fulfill it is he gets a game.

Caldwell and McManus- Drop McManus for Loovens. When Caldwell is bad he is terrible, when he is good he is very good. McManus when bad is terrible, when good is above average.

Brown- Thought we would see more ffrom him this year but doesn't look like that will be the case, major major improvement needed, doesn't seem to know what his job is (has he a clue, is that down to poor man management?)

Hartley- good defencively but needs a creative player beside him to offer options.

Naka- doesn't like the rough and tumble, need the other midfielders to take care of that side of the game and he can creat echances if given the ball

McGeady- top class, Rangers could double team him yesterday as they didn't need to worry about anyone else in our midfield. Has started this season very slowly

Samaras- seems to be better coming off the bench, has been given chances starting but never taken them

Maloney- good player but played out of position yesterday, think he will be a good signing.

Robson- best CM we have, should be playing

JVOH- running was never his strong point (understatement of the year), useful though when played witht he right partner

Answer 10

My honest assessment is.

Boruc - a world class keeper.

McManus - Typical Celtic Captain,stout heart 100 percenter every game.

Brown - honest hard working player no shortage of skill

Nakamura - classy player - can they hold on to him.

Robson,Hartley - decent skillful players.

McGeady great player but has off days more than you would like,

McDonald -  great striker could score in any game.

Venegoor/Samaras - prolific goalscorers.

Maloney - Celtic's best player, one of the best players in Scotland in recent years.I get nervous every time he has possession in or around the box.

Answer 11

Hope you enjoyed your win...  Your very observant thanks for the interest...hahaha      Sure, some players seriously need to be dropped but, we have known that for months.   Gordons problem in my view is - too loyal to certain players.   Anyway, enjoy your win,  it's only one win mind....lol    Like my fellow Celts i always  "keep the faith"...  :)

PS.  Hope you and yours are keeping well.  x

And you always are my dear fellow.   have to agree with you on some of the points.