An offered trade?

Question

some guy offered me brandon jacobs for ronnie brown i decline it but counter it for

jacobs

bernard berrin

veron davis

ronnie brown

zack miller

reggie williams

is that pretty fair

Answer 1

No davis is better than Miller.

Answer 2

Ronnie brown is a question mark for this season.  I would want to wait and see how he's going to play this year.  Maybe you can get a couple of pre-season games out of the way before you make the trade.  If they do the trade where you get Vernon Davis and Berrian I would go ahead and pull the trigger on that.  I think Davis will have a break-out year if he stays healthy.

Answer 3

i think that is a bad trade because this year he is healthy  and he doesn't have to play behind Ricky Williams. Ronnie will be a very special edtion in your and is very valuable. Don't make the trade. And besides, Jacobs and Bradshaw take turns.

Answer 4

Yes that is fair. I think you are getting a better deal then he is.