Another 'should I do this trade' question?

Question

I Get:

Ronald Curry

Maurice Jones-Drew

Fred Taylor

I Give:

Javon Walker

Edgerrin James

Thomas Jones

The loss of Javon Walker wouldn't effect me all that much as I have Plaxico Burress and Wes Welker on my roster. And I'm in need of a another quality RB as the best on my roster at the moment is Ryan Grant.

Answer 1

No, we have no idea what the Jags Rb split will consist of this year, while you KNOW Edge and Thomas are both starting for their teams.  Stick with what you have until we get through training camp so you have a better idea of what to expect.

Answer 2

I definitely understand your dilemma, but I would not pull the trigger on this deal.  Walker has something to prove this year - on many fronts - and will be a valuable WR that could compliment your other WR studs (Burress and Welker) well.  Yes Edge seems to be a subpar back these days, but is giving up two starting RBs in exchange for two RBs on the same team, really the best option?  And finally, Thomas Jones is a starting back who will score more TDs this year.  Try to focus on coupling both James and Jones for one stud RB.  That is definitely a better route than losing out on Walker and taking two RBs from the same squad.

Answer 3

I would agree with Asher on this one.

Answer 4

the only way i would do this deal is if you take out Taylor and Jones and just trade Walker and James for Curry and MoJo.

Answer 5

No WAY If you already have Grant you have got two solid RB and any trade that involves Ronald Curry should be laughted at and rejected right away.