Another fantasy football question?

Question

Who is a better RB and why. Rudi Johnson or Brandon Jacobs?

Answer 1

brandon  jacobs

Answer 2

Rudi Johnson is better, he is slowing down but Brandon Jacobs is still unproven to carry the load and has competition with Bradshaw.

Dont be surprised if Bradshaw beats out B-Jacobs by midseason he is more versatile while B Jacobs is only a straight ahead runner. Bradshaw can go inside/outside and catch passes.

Rudi is at least a 300 carry back and will produce simply on the number of attempts. Plus he is proven.

If your asking because you need a number 3 back I would take Tom Jones or Edge over these guys due to schedule strength and their ability to catch out of the backfield.

I think Edge will have a surprisingly good year, because he is in a contract year!!! dont sleep like everyone else definitely a solid 5th or 6th round pick!!! plus 300 carries are guaranteed...

Answer 3

I heard last night (on ESPN I believe) that Rudi is back at full strength and has in fact added some muscle.  If he is back to his old self, I would take him over Jacobs in a heartbeat.  Rudi has been a very underrated fantasy RB for years- before last year he had 1300-1400 yards and 12 tds for three years in a row, which puts him at the lead of the second tier of RBs.  Jacobs, by contrast, has been the #1 back for one season, and only played 11 games last year.  Also, with Rudi you only need to handcuff one player (Kenny Watson, and if you draft Rudi I would be sure and get Watson), while with Jacobs you have to figure out who will be the #2 back- Bradshaw? Droughns? Ward?  

Both guys have risk, but I would go for the Johnson/Watson handcuff first.

Answer 4

WHAT WOULD YOU RATHER HAVE  A BJ OR RJ HAHA IF YOU CHOSE CORRECTLY THEN YOU WILL KNOW WHO IS RIGHT FOR YOU I HOPE

Answer 5

I would say that Brandon Jacobs is the better of the two running-backs, because the Giants are a much more stable team than the Bengals at the moment.  With all the problems the team has had over this off-season, I would be inclined to stay away from them.  Plus, Rudi is getting hurt more and more in recent seasons, and Jacobs is still very young and is a very powerful runner