Any of these trades an upgrade 4 me?Trade Maine for Lowe , Maine for Garza, Maine for Meche, Pence for Murphy?

Question

Are any of these trades an upgrade for me. Please Help!

I have been proposed: (I have Maine and David Murphy)

Maine for Garza

Maine for Lowe

Maine for Meche

David Murphy for Hunter Pence

Answer 1

none of them can really be consider an upgrade. i dint like the fact that u were trading for meche or garza. they are in no way an upgrade. they are pitchers that u pick up and use while they are hot but are not in anyway helpful to win a league. they are 5 starter at best. they do have moments of greatness like garzas cg last night but is not enough to jump all over him (in my opinion) and the pence for murphy is coming at the wrong time cuz murphy was doing well cuz he had a healthy hamilton and bradley in his side. now with both guys banged up, he can seem to get much done. hope this helped you.

Answer 2

none of those pitcher deals help you, but i'd consider getting Pence for Murphy. i'm a believer in Pence and not scared off by his early slump. if you started tracking their stats today, i think Pence will be the better fantasy contributor the rest of the season.

Answer 3

Maine has looked hot lately, so I do not know if any are good for you. As of now I would hang onto Maine and see if he continues to play good baseball, as of now I believe he is 2-0 in his last two starts.

Good Luck

Answer 4

keep murphy he will win roy this year he is doing alot. pence is a good player but murphy is better. keep murphy he will be a big guy on your franchise