Are Carlton the 2008 disgrace of the AFL?

Question

Carlton had three No. 1 draft picks on the field last week against Essendon...Matt Kreuzer, Marc Murphy & Bryce Gibbs. They had the messiah Chris Judd & all Oz fullforward & 2006 Coleman medalist Fevola!

They have not won a game since Ratten (the Rat) took over as coach last year & are going to break the record of most losses since 1901-2.

How pathetic are they? Between them all they can't even raise a whimper. No wonder they have a nick-name of "The Blues" - they certainly couldn't have a name indicating anything animal like or ferocious!

Answer 1

True... I blame the coaching staff. They play totally uninspired.... a bore to watch. Talent does mean anything if it is not directed properly.

Oh - and Cutemum is insane. The Pies are going to trounce them.

Answer 2

i guess you could say that

Answer 3

nothing like the west coke eagles and the STUFF at goes down in perth or is that up

Answer 4

Yes. I reckon they are.

Carlton boast a line up of some recognized talent - Jeez, weren't we bombarded enough about that & how well the team would do, pre season?

Whereas poor old Melbourne, didn't tank & battled away, winning enough games in past seasons not to get such draft concessions afforded to Carlton.

Answer 5

Yes. One does have to agree.

As someone else said. One thing certain; if losing is an expertise Carlton are the best placed outfit in the AFL to write the definitive thesis on the subject.

Answer 6

brent staker  is weak!!!

Answer 7

The blues are a better side on paper then a few, but can not put it together, ratten probably can't coach.

Answer 8

This is a pathetic little dig of a question but hey I'll answer by saying no -not as much of a disgrace as the rest of the west coke druggies that DID NOT FLY THE FLAG,after their team mate went down like a bag of $h!t

Hunter ran in then was so scared he fell over after Barry hall put one finger on him. Brent stakers team mates were PATHETIC. have a good one .

Answer 9

Yes, Carlton are a disgrace for 2008.

Plus, I 'tank' they were a disgrace during 2007. I also 'tank' they were a disgrace the year before. I 'tank' they have been a disgrace for a long time now.

Answer 10

yean i think your right there

Answer 11

i would throw in your team in that bracket this year they look insipid

Answer 12

The reason I would say no is that they have admitted they are in a rebuilding phase so that does give them some to very little credibility. Disappointing would be a better term for them due to the reasons you have given.

The Demons, WCE or Port who have not come out and stated this are more the disgraces as they have not recognised their problems to the fans.

Answer 13

agree with the last poster, but will add that youre obviously still bitter about judd leaving your druggie club

Answer 14

Not yet.

Ratten is not the man.

Answer 15

Call me INSANE,but I went for them against the Maggies tomorrow.

Answer 16

Yes. Carlton   are absolutely shocking.

I'm predicting a 60 point + win by Collingwood .

They'd be lucky to win their games against Melbourne and Richmond, let alone anyone else.

Ratten should be sacked by the end of this year.