Are Pisces compatible with other Pisces?

Question

I would say yes and no because I was married to Pisces but it didn't work out. We divorced each other because we loved each other too much. This probably doesn't make sense to most people nor myself sometimes.

Is being too compatible not compatible?

Answer 1

They must be.  My parents were both Pisces and they were the happiest couple I ever knew.

Answer 2

my wife and I both are...I would say we are pretty compatible.  

Answer 3

I say no. Pisces is a negative sign and it needs more of a positive sign.

Im virgo and im also a negative sign, meaning that im more pessimist than optimistic, and people need a balance. to have this balance a negative sign has to be with a positive one to be compatible. Im virgo and I need a positive sign that boosts my confidence when I feel low or someone who is more aggressive in a positive way, kind of like a leader.

Pisces is fantasy sign who likes all creativity and appreciates arty stuff that sorrounds them, they get so lost in that other world that they sometimes hate the fact of hitting rock bottom reality. Two Pisces together are such in much harmony and so much to give each other that when reality needs to be taken care of none of the two want to leave la la land, and this is when these two clash because one or the other need to take the innitiative of responsibility in real life. here is an example of two pisces living together: A(female) B(male)

A. "honey, did u pay the water bill?

B. I thought you did.

A. no, I thought you did.

B. well, I go pay for it later on today.

A. ok

TWO WEEKS LATER...

A. "honey, why are they sending us a late charge notice?

didn't you pay the bill already?

B. oh, yeah im on it, I just had so many things to do that I forgot,

but i'll pay for it tomorrow.

A. ok, I cant take all the responsibility you know.

B. I know, I said Im on it.

TWO MORE WEEKS...

A. ahhhh!, theres no water coming out!

B. what, how come?

LOL, just kidding, but in a sense they are too relaxed to worry about

life situations that can stress them out, and two pisces are too laid back depending on each other.

Answer 4

Pisces with Pisces is the dreamiest mixture there is - you dream of rescuing the princess, she dreams of her knight in shining armor.

Sounds lovely, right? Ha! Pisces like to dream about their fairy tale coming true, and that's exactly what both of you will do.  

To the other zodiac signs it'll appear you're living in your own little fantasy world, a fairy tale if you will, but that doesn't surprise you now does it Pisces? You're always  misunderstood anyway, right?  

I understand you though. I know what happens when two dreamers dream alone together.................Will it be you or her? That's the only question here - one of you is going to rehab!

Answer 5

Hi Sean,

Being a piscean myself I get along with my piscean fellows really good. But when it comes to compatibility, there's more than sunsigns. Planets and their aspects with each other matter a lot. I wonder what in your natal charts caused this divorcement and excessive love.

Also roughly I can say water signs go well with water and earth signs

Air signs go well with air and fire signs. Libra (air) Cancer (water)

But this is a generalised info, natal and synastry charts matter.

As an answer to your question I'd say yes, pisces-pisces relationship would be highly spiritual, experimental, dreamy and flighty.

Take care

Answer 6

It has absolutely nothing to do with what month you were born in.  What makes people compatible is the ability and willingness to get along with each other.

Answer 7

I'm a pisces, and my boyfriend of a long time is also a pisces. We are very compatible. We also both have a gemini moon. I think we learn a lot from eachother as well.

But hey, I think I understand what you mean by you loved eachother too much. Maybe it takes a pisces relationship to understand that concept... so much emotion and intensity sometimes... you wanted the best for eachother.. to have a 'normal' life.

I think pisces relationships have the potential to be so out of this world, for better or worse.

Answer 8

yeass,

your sign is not like scorpio,

where they would love eachother then litterly kill eachother(there very suspiciouse) but no those 2 togteher sound fine, pisces are very nice calm soothing people personaly i love them, im scorpio and i get along with them best, frenship and love wise,

but yeah this sounds good to me!

Answer 9

yes.  You can be too similar.  I think Pisces/Pisces relationships ability to work really depend on what else is in their charts.  Some can be out of this world because you get each other, and some you can be too similar to really work.  That is one of the dangers with same sign pairings is that you are too similar - you have the same strengths and weaknesses and can't really compliment each other.  I personally don't like to date Pisces men (and I have dated quite a few of them), I prefer fixed signs where we can compliment each other.  The love of my life and my soulmate is a Scorpio and he's perfect for me.  But, at the end of the day it comes down to your whole chart.