Are atlanta braves the opnly team in history with 3! pitchers who will be in hall of fame?

Question

i mean glavine, with over 300 wins, maddux, with over 300 and smoltz!! we all know those men will! be in hall! who else can claim to have 3 pitchers! on SAME STAFF IN HALL?

Answer 1

No

Answer 2

Who says Maddux will be going to the HOF as a Brave?

Answer 3

The following staffs had 4 HOF pitchers

1912 A's - Pennock, Bender, Coveleski, Plank

1930 Yankees - Pennock, Ruffing, Gomez, Hoyt

1933-34 Cardinals - Dean, Grimes, Vance, Haines

1949 Indians - Feller, Wynn, Paige, Lemon

1954 Indians - Feller, Wynn, Newhauser, Lemon

From 1949 to 1956 the Indians had Feller, Wynn, and Lemon

From 1993 to 1999 the Braves had Smoltz, Glavine, and Maddux

edit: Why on earth would somebody give this a thumbs down???

Answer 4

O.K. There's one. But you can't compare the BIG THREE: SMOLTZ, GLAVINE AND MADDUX with Cone, Pettitte and Clemens because:

-Maybe Roger Clemens will not be in Cooperstown since his HGH scandal.

-Pettite is good but he never was extraordinary.

-David Cone doesn't have spectacular numbers like the Big three do.

-They didn't play together so many time as Glavine, Smoltz and Maddux.

Answer 5

Good catch Sandman - but I'll go one step further. The 1930 Yankees had 4 Hall of Fame pitchers. Red Ruffing, Herb Pennock, Lefty Gomez and Waite Hoyt.

Answer 6

Pizzaman... who cares if they get into the hall of fame.  the yanks won world championships with these guys pitching, the braves didnt

Answer 7

New York Yankees

Waite Hoyt

Steve Coveleski

Herb Pennock

all pitched together in 1928  on the same staff

and i think you wanna say "HAD" on the same staff, since maddux is in San Diego

and there are other guys you can cases for: Clemens, Cone, and Pettite all were on the same staff