Are manual transmissions just as safe as automatic transmission cars?

Question

I think so!

Answer 1

The safety of a vehicle doesn't have anything to do with the transmission!

Answer 2

The question should be are drivers safe but really both are safe.

Answer 3

automatic is more safe compared to stick b/c there's less things  u have to do than manual. still depends on driver

Answer 4

No...The only time any vehicle is 'safe' is when nobody is inside of it and the engine is off...Stick or auto trans choice is just a personal preference...Some like to be more involved with the operation of the vehicle...Most auto drivers tend to get better gas mileage though.

Answer 5

Depends on the experience of the driver.

Answer 6

In a crash, you get hurt the same. :-)

Now days, I doubt the Manual is better.  People does makes mistakes so is more likely to have an incident due to improper gear or clutch slippage or any other thing.

There was a time where manual trannies were better.  Due to the fact that Auto were too heavy and had fewer gears.  So as far performance is kind of sluggish.  Automatics came with a hefty price as an added feature.

Now the Car Computer does the shifting for you when is optimal for power and comfort.  The car even "learn" your driving habits.   It has from 4 to even 8 gears (VW Tiptronic has 6).  Direct Shift is coming and there is not way that you can out shift an automatic with a manual.

Still used on racing since it gives freedom to the driver to do changes at will and lighter weight.  For street purpose is pretty neglectable.

I remember people taking the 747 Torque Flite Chrysler Automatics for drag racing, with the electric push button shifter.  Done properly smoked a lot of cars with manual tranies out there.

Answer 7

what do you mean by safe?i drive both and feel safe .

Answer 8

Not only are they safer, they are also cheaper to fix if something goes wrong with your tranny. We own 3 cars and they are all newer than 05 and they are all stick shift.

Answer 9

Yes they are.  They do require a little more effort when you are on you cell phone.