Are you a twilight reader?

Question

if so...

who do u like better Edward or Jacob and why?

I have read all 4 books and i say Edward all the way but one of my friends says Jacob.

idk what do u think?

Answer 1

edward, but I still love jacob. I wanted bella with edward and Jacob to be truly happy.

Answer 2

Definitely team Jacob!!!!!! im the only 1 out of all my friends who likes him : ( i love him, he's so funny and rebellious and i love how he helps Bella with the whole motorbike thing!!!! i don't hate edward though, even if he is annoyingly protective sometimes!!!!!

Answer 3

Yes.  I like Edward better for Bella, but Jacob better for me.  Jacob seems more down-to-earth.  I loved the ending to Breaking Dawn.  

Answer 4

Edward definity!!! I is so loving.  

Answer 5

YES!

i agree with you

i have always been on Edward's side

he is the dream guy

Answer 6

I have read all the books and I am one of the few Jacob fans out there.

There aren't many of us but we are just as loyal as Edward fans. Don't

take it the wrong way I think Edward is really cool too but I just like Jacob better. I knw it isn't in your question but I also love Alice. GO ALICE!!

Answer 7

I'm 100% Team Edward baby! Even though I have nothing against Jacob, I would prefer Edward. And I agree with the Alice thing! She rocks! I wrote a fan-fic from her P.O.V! (point of view) *high five back*

I think the ending of Breaking Dawn rocked! It was so cool how Edward was finally able to read Bella's mind. But I thought the thing with the Voltri was too long. Lol, for some reason, Aro reminds me of a hippy! "Peace Brother" Tee-hee.

Over all, I would be very happy if the book from Renesmee's P.O.V becomes a reality! "Keep reading, don't let anyone stop you. -Max"  

Answer 8

I'm 14 and love romance books, but this was WAY to cliche for me.

Answer 9

EDWARD ANTHONY MASEN CULLEN!!!

I LOVE him!!!!! He's really the most perfect guy any girl could ever dream of!!! He's overprotective in a good way, understanding, the most intellectual being I have ever known(read), and last but never the least, he's soooooo hot!!!

I've read all four books and thought of them really great! The best series I have ever read! Breaking Dawn for me is not really the best book of the four, I'd still say Twilight. Because, there's not much romance or bella and edward scenes there. It only revolved around Renesmee and I am actually disappointed of the outcome. And I hated Breaking Dawn more because along the way while I was reading my "devoted" love for Edward wavered and I kind of liked Jacob! Because of him narrating and all, it's actually kind of cool. I told myself noooooo freaking way!!! so after reading Breaking Dawn, I re-read New moon and Eclipse again and I again hated Jacob lol! And then later, I figured out that the reason I liked him is because of the actor playing the role Jacob! Which is by the way also cute!!! Taylor Launter! BUT NOT AS HOT AS ROBERT PATTINSON!!! He's insanely hot!

Answer 10

Edward all the way for me too. Although both Jacob and Edward have their own imperfections, although people may argue otherwise on the Edward factor :D

I mean Edward is my dream man, he can really do no wrong. But let's face it...he is just a tad...or a tad more, over protective, don't you think? He does things that HE thinks are best for Bella. What about what she wants?

Jacob however I feel deeply sorry for. Bella used him when she needed sunshine in her life to substitute for Edward, and then she threw him out like an unwanted pup after christmas.

I'd say overall Edward, but Jacob has definitely earned a spot in my heart. :)

And I think that the ending of Breaking Dawn was far too happy. I was expecting someone to die for sure. I mean, what with all the build up to the Volturri, and then all of a sudden they resolve it in one conversation?

Not Meyer's usual standard unfortunately...even though I look up to her as a writer no matter what. :)

Answer 11

yes...*team edward*...i don't have nething AGAINST jacob, but i prefer edward as a person and he is the hottest guy on the planet so what's not to like?

Answer 12

Jacob! xD His much better..  

Answer 13

I prefered Jacob, because he was more human (I found Edward's perfection boring).  However, I never really had any hope of Bella choosing Jacob, and I think that was one of the weaknesses of the series.  It would have been more interesting, and more suspenceful if she had been more torn between the two of them.

And as for Jacob imprinting on Nessie - no, I found that a bit creepy quite frankly, I would have prefered him to imprint on some nice girl his own age, and I would have liked it if Bella had been a teeny bit jealous because she still quite liked Jacob herself.  Because life is complicated, and the way the Twilight saga ended was just too glib and cosy, there wasn't enough drama.