Arrange these wicket-keepers rankwise according to ur point of view?

Question

M.S.Dhoni

P.Patel

K.Akmal

Moin Khan

A.Gilchrist

B.Haddin

M.Boucher

A.B.De Villers

K.Sangakkara

P.Jayawerdene

P.Nixon

A.Stewart

C.McCullum

R.Jecobs

D.Ramdin

T.Taibu

A.Flower

M.Rahim

Answer 1

A.Gilchrist

M.Boucher

K.Sangakkara

A.Flower

M.S.Dhoni

C.McCullum

A.Stewart

K.Akmal

Moin Khan

B.Haddin

R.Jacobs

T.Taibu

A.B.De Villers

P.Patel

P.Nixon

P.Jayawerdene

D.Ramdin

M.Rahim

Answer 2

A.Gilchrist

M.S.Dhoni

M.Boucher

Moin Khan

A.B.De Villers

K.Sangakkara

P.Jayawerdene

A.Stewart

C.McCullum

B.Haddin

T.Taibu

K.Akmal

P.Nixon

P.Patel

R.Jecobs

D.Ramdin

A.Flower

M.Rahim

Answer 3

One way of ranking wicket keepers is based on Victims (catches + stumpings) per match.

Test Matches: Bradley Haddin (5.33); Adam Gilchrist (4.33); Mark Boucher (3.81); Kamran Akmal (3.74); Ridley Jacobs (3.37); Denesh Ramdin (3.11); Brendon McCullum (3.06); Kumar Sangakkara (3); MS Dhoni (2.83); Prasanna Jayawardene (2.67); Andrew Flower (2.54); Abraham B De villiers (2.5); Parthiv Patel (2.45); Tatendu Taibu (2.17); Moin Khan (2.14); Alec Stewart (2.08); Mushfiqur Rahim (1); Paul Nixon (Not played any test match).

    

Answer 4

A.Gilchrist

M.Boucher

K.Sangakkara

A.Flower

A.Stewart

C.McCullum

M.S.Dhoni

Moin Khan

R.Jecobs

A.B.De Villers

K.Akmal

T.Taibu

P.Jayawerdene

P.Nixon

P.Patel

B.Haddin

M.Rahim

D.Ramdin

And forget Ian Healy and Nayan Mondia.

They should have been in the list....

I was greatly disappointed when Ian Healy name was not on the list...

Answer 5

Acc. to me-

1-Adam Gilchrist- Winner in the list

2-Andy Flower- My favourite & still rank him a bit lesser I think

3-Mark Boucher- under rated & possess great fitness

3-Kumar Sangakkara- class act

5-Alec Stewart- one of the greats

6-Brendon McCullum- His keeping is amazing, he took a catch behind the stumps against Eng which is arguably the best catch by a WK acc. to me

7-Kamran Akmal- One of the few bright spots in p**i cricket atm

8-Moin Khan- Agressive & he knew whats called smart keeping.

9-MS Dhoni- He would go higher in the list with time I'm sure

10-Ridley Jacobs- I can quite compare him with Stewart & Boucher in some grounds but he was a bit stiffer so I put him here compared to the ones above

11-Tatenda Taibu- athletic, enthusiastic, got less than what he deserved

12-Paul Nixon- A bit of an "over-analyser" when either he bats or keeps, not sure if its his weakness or strength

I'm not ranking the following players because I believe they still have some hidden attributes which are to be seen-

Brad Haddin- Lacks some Gilchrist charisma but I think he'll improve

AB De Villers- he certainly has the potential but needs to prove more whether he can take up the added resposiblity

M.Rahim- talented & quick behind the stumps & he's got a bright future ahead

P.Jayawerdene- looks promising, will see!

D.Ramdin- Quite average keeper acc. to me, his agility seems to be his advantage though

P.Patel- I'm never really impressed from him to be honest, maybe he was pushed into the international arena too early & that worked against him.

Answer 6

K.Sangakkara

A.Gilchrist

M.S.Dhoni

C.McCullum

A.Flower

M.Boucher

A.B.De Villers

A.Stewart

K.Akmal

Moin Khan

B.Haddin

T.Taibu

R.Jecobs

P.Patel

D.Ramdin

P.Jayawerdene

P.Nixon

M.Rahim

Answer 7

K.Sangakkara

A.Gilchrist

M.S.Dhoni

C.McCullum

A.Flower

M.Boucher

A.B.De Villers

A.Stewart

K.Akmal

Moin Khan

B.Haddin

T.Taibu

R.Jecobs

P.Patel

D.Ramdin

P.Jayawerdene

P.Nixon

M.Rahim

Answer 8

A.Gilchrist

K.Sangakkara

M.Boucher

M.S.Dhoni

AB De Villiers

A.Flower

A.Stewart

D.Ramdin

C.McCullum

T.Taibu

B.Haddin

M.Rahim

M.Khan

K.Akmal

P.Patel

P.Nixon

R.Jecobs

P.Jayawardene

Answer 9

A. Gilchrist

K. Sangakkara

A. Flower

M.S. Dhoni

A.Stewart

B.McCullum (guessing who you meant)

M.Boucher

Moin Khan

K.Akmal

A.B De Villers

B.Haddin

P.Jayawerdene

D.Ramdin

T.Taibu

P.Patel

R.Jacobs

M.Rahim

P.Nixon