As commissioner, should i disallow a trade of Chipper/CC/CJ Wilson for Miggy/Taveras/Borowski?

Question

Seems to me like it is definitely lopsided, as CC is getting better and is an ace. I feel Miggy/Chipper and CJ Wilson/Borowski is even, but Taveras and CC don't even come close in my mind. Maybe I am over thinking it, so tell me what you think.

Answer 1

don't veto it.

The person giving away chipper is probably expecting an injury, and historically Cabrera outperforms him in the long run.

This is a fair trade. Someone may benefit in the end, but it is definitely not one-sided enough to veto.

Answer 2

dont veto it

Answer 3

I see no reason to veto this trade unless there is some kind of collusion involved. There does not appear to be any.

I feel for you putting yourself in this situation. I would either let the league vote or let Yahoo handle it.

Good luck. Have fun.

Answer 4

don't veto it.  i'm sick of fantasy leaguers getting all up in arms about every single trade that happens....if a trade was perfectly even, why would teams ever trade?  Unless these two guys are colluding and doing things that are obviously fishy to benefit one side, i would let it go.

Answer 5

Who ever is offering Taveras needs to up the ante a tad to even it out. Overall though its not too one sided. Chipper and Mags are quite a haul.