Ashlyn Olivia or Reagan Rylee....baby girl name decision?!?!?

Question

Hi!

I am currently 24 weeks pregnant and for the past few months, my husband and I have been calling our little girl Ashlyn, the only name we could both seem to agree on!

A few nights ago, I had a dream that we named our daughter Reagan Rylee and I woke up really liking it! I told my husband about this name, really thinking he would object, and he wants to consider it!

We have a three year old daughter now named Kendal Rae, and I personally think that Reagan Rylee compliments her name well. The problem is, now I am confused since we now have 2 names that we both agree on and like. What sounds better with our daughters name now, or which name do you like better? The middle name for Ashlyn would be Olivia. We are not looking for additional names, but an opinion on the two current names we have. She is due in November! Thanks for all your help!

~ Miracle baby number two on her way!

Answer 1

I don't like Reagan Rylee it is too many R's all together.

I like Reagan Olivia, or Rylee Olivia, and Ashlyn Olivia

Answer 2

I like Ashlyn.  It's not common yet not out in left field, either.

Answer 3

Reagan Rylee

Answer 4

I love Ashlyn Olivia.  That's gorgeous!  But if your gut tells you to pick Reagan Rylee you may want to choose that one.  Go with your gut on this one.

Answer 5

i think you had a great dream...go with the dream name!!  and i agree that it compliments your other daughters name nicely.   good luck

Answer 6

Please name your child Ashlyn Olivia.  That's a name she can be proud of and she won't be picked on for it.  If her name is Reagan, she'll get asked if she was named after the president and plus, Reagan is a LAST name.  Sure, it sounds nice, but it's not a good idea.  Rylee....Omg, that is a DOG name!  I know 4 dogs named Riley!

Ashlyn Olivia 100% it's a beautiful, feminine name.

Answer 7

ashlyn olivia is really pretty

Answer 8

Ashlyn Olivia is my fav of the two. And I LOVE the middle name Olivia.

Man this is hard though cause Reagan Rylee definitely goes with your other daughter's name better. Reagan flows off the tongue much easier than Ashlyn. But it's also getting really popular right now so it might feel trendy down the line.

Ok I changed my mind. I say Reagan.

I see your problem here. Hehe. Oh well there are worse problems than having two names you both love.

IS REAGAN OLIVIA A CHOICE?

Answer 9

Ashlyn Olivia is BEAUTIFUL! Reagan Rylee is cute, but Ashlyn Olivia is so much prettier. :)  

Answer 10

Ashlyn Olivia is beautiful. I LOVE it. It is one of my pics for my baby.

Great Minds Think Alike.  

Answer 11

They are both really great names but i think Ashlyn Olivia is realy cute .

Answer 12

I like Ashlyn Olivia, but if it were turned around I would like better. Olivia Ashlyn is pretty.

Answer 13

I would go with Ashlyn Olivia. Not too crazy aout the 2 R's in the other name. And it would be too matchy with your other daughter's name too.

Answer 14

I prefer Ashlyn Olivia. I would think Reagan Rylee was a boy.. I would assume Kendal and Ashlyn were brother and sister. I would assume Kendal and Reagan were brothers though.

I guess I would prefer for a girl name to be used on a girl so regardless of how it goes with your daughters name or how it makes it sound, I prefer Ashlyn Olivia.  

Answer 15

I like Reagan Olivia....but sticking to just the choices given I would say Ashlyn Olivia

Answer 16

Ashlyn Olivia is adorable.  I love it.  Definitely that one.  

Answer 17

I think Ashlyn Olivia is much cuter and flows together better.