Baker, Garza, or Guthrie? - Fantasy Baseball?

Question

I have to drop one of these pitchers on my staff, who should I drop?

Answer 1

Keep Garza. He was a top prospect for the Twins and his stuff is real good.  Plus he's on the better team right now.

Answer 2

Guthrie. He may benefit you in ERA, but nothing else. At least Baker and Garza can win. Guthrie's team, Orioles, can't help him score.

Answer 3

Guthrie.  DO NOT drop Garza.  He is on fire, and has much more upside then the other guys you mentioned.  Baker has lots of strikeouts and is playing for the Red Hot Twins.

Guthrie plays for Baltimore which kills his wins.