Baseball Keeper League - D. Wright or Longoria?

Question

which 3B would you rather have in a keeper league and why?

i already have one of the two, but a trade proposal gives me the option of the other. if i take it, the trade scores me a top of the line pitcher to keep as well.

Answer 1

You gotta go with the proven player: D Wright. The keeper league will not last all that long and you should take Wright who has been consistant.

Answer 2

longoria because he will last longer.

Answer 3

Wow...tough choice. I guess I would be inclined to keep Wright siomply because he is still very young himself and his past 3 year ave. of around 30 HR, 110 RBI, 105 runs, close to 30 SB and a .320 ba.. I really think Longoria has a shot to be special but it is awful hard to give away such great proven numbers. And to do it in the limelight that is NY is special, lord knows he still hasnt hit his prime (25 yrs. old, wont turn 26 until Dec.) so in a tough call I say stick with the proven Hall of Fame type numbers and keep Wright.