Baseball Trade Help?

Question

I would be trading

Utley

Carlos Queintin

Trevor Hoffman

I would be getting

Kinsler

Matt Holliday

Roy Halladay

What should i do make the trade or turn away????

Answer 1

Utley = Kinsler

Holiday better than Quentin

Halladay WAY BETTER than Hoffman.

Run right now to your page and take the trade!!!!!

Answer 2

Make the trade.  Kinsler is pretty d**n good, Holliday and Halladay are great!  Hoffman is old, Quentin is good, Utley is great.

Answer 3

make the trade unless Hoffman is your best closer

Answer 4

its only the start of the 2nd half....however it depends on your team needs. with holiday you know what you're going to get. also if you have good relievers then its ok to make this trade.

Answer 5

I would accept in a heartbeat.

Yeah, you're giving up Utley, but Kinsler is good and has a great supporting cast around him.

Quentin may have 22 HRs, but he has an average like .250-.260 range.  Holliday is a .300 hitter who will hit at least 30 HRs and drive in 100 RBIs

Hoffman is the concern.  If there are any relievers (Kobayashi of the Indians for example) get one of those replacement closers.  But, Halladay is pitching well again this year and will keep it up.

This guy is an idiot so take the deal

Answer 6

Take it. Utley is the best second baseman around but Kinsler is amazing too. Quentin really does not compare to Matt Holliday. Holliday will do even better in the second half of this season. Halladay is a stud pitcher and Hoffman is a reliever who is like 1234558 years old.

Answer 7

I take it this trade was proposed to you?

This isn't bad,but still I'd counter offer to see if this guy will give you more...He may REALLY want Utley,so see if you can milk another player you want from his team.

~G{}{}d Luck!~