Baseball fans: Did the redsox win/lose/neither in the blockbuster trade?

Question

Please star

Did it help?

Hurt?

Answer 1

It is definitely going to hurt the Red Sox.  Their offense has been anemic and losing Manny is going to hurt run production.  

Tomorrow would have taken care of itself.  

The Red Sox could have easily paid Manny and despite the fact that everyone knows that he is a bum, everyone loves to have him in the lineup.    

Answer 2

I think the Red Sox lose. They had to give up there best hitter, two prospects, and they had to pay his contract. That was a bad deal for the Red Sox

Answer 3

I would think that they lost the trade since they traded manny who is better than bay and they even lost 2 prospects.  However, the Redsox have won 2 world series with this general manager and owner, so I would think they would know what they are doing maybe he is too distracting.    

Answer 4

They lost as far as I'm concerned, it's going to hurt them for a long time.

Answer 5

I think it hurt them and me , the Red s0x because Bay numbers are almost  equally but Bay has never played in critical games and Bay is hitting like .220 with risp

and i am suffering because my brother doesn't shut the h**l up with the MANNY trade

Answer 6

It helped. He scored both runs last night so he has now accomplished more in a Red Sox jersey than Manny ever did. Plus he made an awesome catch.

Answer 7

I'm glad Manny is gone...his attitude and whining was hurting the entire team and bringing them down. He's been whining forever to be traded and now he finally has been.  

Answer 8

If you are looking at pure talent they lost but it was something that had to be done and will improve the overall performance of the sox for the rest of this season and beyond.

Answer 9

psshhh they lost... everybody lost except for dodgers

Answer 10

They lost because Manny is a future hall of famer and i'm not sure if Bay is gonna go somewhere.