Baseball: is this a good deal i think it is

Question

i get ryan braun, jj hardy and prince fielder

i give manny ramiez,derek jeter and ryan howard

Answer 1

noo i dont think so...

Answer 2

It sounds good but I wouldn't do it.

Answer 3

I think its 50-50 although You do get younger players in return so it is a good deal

Answer 4

Nah i wouldn't do it.

Answer 5

No. All the players you get are on the same team. Thats the only downside. If the Brew Crew have an off day, you're screwed and will get no production out of any of them.

Answer 6

I'm not sure that I like this trade unless it's a keeper league. There is more power w/ the players you're giving up.

Answer 7

yes that is a very good trade

Answer 8

U R Ripped Off

Answer 9

no, not really

Answer 10

Well you just have to analyze considering your trading positions.

Braun is a top OF and better than Manny but Manny is playing well right now.

Jeter, although is not a great fantasy player, is better than Hardy.

And Fielder and Howard are as close to a push as possible.

Its really what you think about it. I wouldnt do it because your getting 3 Brewers.

And also depends on what kind of league you play in, cause your gaining average just by switching Fielder and Howard. And you are gaining in the age department.