Been offered G Sizemore, A Gonzalez, and J Hardy for Rollins and M. Cabrera.?

Question

This is in a H2H keeper league in which we can keep 4 players each year. Which side wins?

Answer 1

the one that gets sizemore gonzalez and hardy

Answer 2

It depends on where you are standing right now. If you are in contention I wouldn't do that deal because I think Cabrera will be the fantasy MVP of the 2nd half. If you are looking towards next season then I'd consider it depending upon who else you are keeping. If Hardy doesn't make your top 4 then probably not. Hardy isn't a fantasy stud like Rollins but he benefits from having a great offense around him.

Answer 3

you know I was going to answer this question with nothing to say about the other people but do not listen to that dumbass that said that gonzalez is a worthless fantasy player. Do the trade because Gonzalez was a number 1 overall pick and he is having a great year and he had a great one last year and he is not old so you cannot say that he is not keeper league worthy. Then J-Roll for Hardy seems very unfair because you are getting some c**p named jj hardy who got in a hot streak and thats why his numbers are like that. But think of it as you are getting Sizemore and a replacement SS for Rollins I know I would much rather have Sizemore than rollins and anyway they are both younger that J-Roll. So shut the **** up dumbass named heat come up with something original not some peice of c**p of a name like heat.

Answer 4

Why would you give up Rollins/Cabrera for essentially Sizemore/Hardy?

Cabrera is dual-position available, and Rollins is worth more than Hardy (still hasn't been caught stealing in 30 plus attempts)

Cabrera will get hot, don't worry.  Hardy will finish with avg stats.

Also, Gonzalez is a worthless fant player.