Bella and Edward query?

Question

this occurred to me the other night that when Bella and Edward made love for the first time wouldn't she be somewhat wrong, correct me if I'm wrong but isn't Edward dead?

Answer 1

Yes, Edward is technically dead. All bodily fluids including sperm turn into venom. Apparently, in Stephenie's world, vampire and human can have babies but vampire and vampire can't. Which is weird, because, a weak human can carry some demon growth spawn that's crushing her pelvis and ribs but a strong vampire can't? But it IS Stephenie's rules, so let her live it.

Answer 2

ya i kno that was so weird!! cuz it's lk hes not even human so how could he still have sperm

Answer 3

Okay don't call it lame. Your reading a book with Vamps and Werewolves in it. What do u expect? Everything to be logical? She is still human until she gives birth to nessy, and then edward turns her. And some how that does happen.

Answer 4

its kinda confusing SM kinda contradicted herself

thats why i though breaking dawn sucked too many plotholes

Answer 5

yet another reason why Breaking dawn doesn't make sense

I mean especially since SMeyer has previously said that all bodily fluid gets turned into venom when you turn into a vampire

sperm = bodily fluid the last time I checked

Answer 6

tts why i amthinking, shouldn't his sperms be too old?

and if he is super low on body temp, wont she freeze to death?

and if she is a vampire, how can she give birth later?

when will her menstruation stop? does it mean she can give birth for hte rest pf her life?

Answer 7

The sperm would have died because his body isn't fully working. So you do have a point there.

Answer 8

Him being an incubus is a bit stupid since they are an evil demon which impregnates you in your sleep.

One assumes it is like the virgin mary.

Answer 9

stephenie meyer has explained that vampire venom sort of replaces sperm...hence why Renesmee was part vampire...if Edward had sperm she would probably be just a normal human child...but there is vampire venom inside of her...

yeah...it's a pretty weak explanation but it does explain things...sort of...

Answer 10

I guess it happened somehow, even if he doesn't have any sperm. I know, that sounds so weird. Ask Stephenie Meyer, she probably has an answer.  

Answer 11

On page 126, Stephenie has her "explanation" about the sperm thing.