Best at 147?

Question

Okay, so let me begin gy saying Cotto and Margarito put on a show that more than lived up to the hype. And while I had Cotto ahead 6 rounds to 4 going into the 11th, all credit to Margarito for standing up to whatever Cotto threw to come back with just as much fire, and then to decisively finish him. Great win.

That being said, this is the question: Margarito beat Cotto. But, let's not forget, Margarito lost a clear decision to Paul Williams. So who is the top guy at 147 - Margarito or Williams?

Answer 1

Magarito and Williams should have a rematch,the winner would clearly be the undisputed Welterweight champion

Answer 2

Margarito.

Although Williams KO'd Quintana, I see Margarito beating Williams the second time around.  Margarito just has to put more pressure on Williams from round 1.  I can't see Williams knocking out Margarito.

Margarito would seal his status in a fight with Mayweather.

I can't see Cotto fighting Margarito anytime soon, but I think it'll happen again.

Answer 3

I would say margarito.......because he started real slow against paul but still put up a h**l of a fight.....right now its margarito hands down....period

Answer 4

I say Margarito. i think Williams-Quintana needs to be trilogy before he fights Margo again. and i still put Cotto before Williams. My list is.

1. Margarito

2. Cotto

3. Williams

Answer 5

Magarito, even if it was a bad night against Williams, he doesn't need a rematch to justify his greatness. But, he may feels he needs it, so does everyone else by the looks of things, but I wouldn't buy that fight nor would I wake up early in South Africa to watch that fight. I'd love to see Magarito now with the limelight on his side vs Mayweather as an underdog in a makeable fight.

Answer 6

Williams????? He probably sh*ted on his pants when he saw the strategy Margarito put on Cot to. The fight with Williams was a mistake of under estimating him, thinking of the next fight instead of Williams. If you saw the Margarito Williams fight youll notice that Margarito was coming back at the end but it was too late