Better pound for pound all-time - Mosely or Mayweather?

Question

All things considered not just who is better right now - opposition, skills at their peak, etc.

Answer 1

Mosely, better fighter aggressively and more fun to watch fight

Answer 2

It's hard to answer 'cause Floyd hasn't begun his decline yet as Sugar Shane has.  When all is said and done I feel Floyd will be better all-time pound 4 pound.

Answer 3

DEFENTLY FLOYD MOSELY IS AN AMAZING FIGHTER BUT FLOYD IS GUNA B AN ALL TIME GREAT

Answer 4

I would have to go with Mayweather...

Answer 5

Lets put it this way. Mayweather has said Shane Mosely couldn't go 5 rounds with him! Well if that's the case then why does he keep ducking Mosely? Hmmmm....Cause he knows Mosely would all but kill him in the least of 3 rounds! And yeah, Mayweather fought an old and slow Oscar last year. Other than that who the h**l has that bumb ACTUALLY fought? NOBODY!

Answer 6

Mayweather

Answer 7

It`s hard to say. Had Vernon Forrest not beat down Mosley I think the Mosley who fought DLH could of whipped Floyd fairly easy. Unfortunately losing badly takes something out of fighters that they never seem to regain.My only hope is Mayweather sticks around long enough to get his clock cleaned.

Answer 8

If floyd would defend his belt instead of fighting these big money fights where he is not really in harms way and he stayed defeated I would say floyd. For me to call a all=time P4P, I have to look at who they beat,how they beat them, their loses etc, shane lost to winky and vernon in a weight division he had no buisness in. and then his lost to cotto was due to his age. and since floyd is beating up guys that he should beat up and  having dominating wins anymore like he use to, i would probably give it a tie at their peak

Answer 9

It's tough to compare because Mosely has fought better competition at a bigger weight,  if PBF steps up the competition a little and wins then I'll give him the edge but if PBF were to retire right now then I would say a tie.  I think a Cotto fight could settle the argument even though I thought the Cotto and Mosely fight was pretty close.

Answer 10

Let's see:  Mayweather never lost and Mosley spent 24 rounds throwing pebbles at a stone wall named Winky.  He also was beaten twice by Vernon Forrest, a fighter who can barely put butts in Free seats.  

Mosley fought better fighters but, besides Oscar, they all beat him.   I wanna give more credit to Shane because at least he lost to a fighter whom it seems Floyd is avoiding.

COTTO!!!

But I have to give the not to Floyd.  He has'nt lost yet.  

COTTO! man,  Nobody wants to see Floyd-Oscar 2