Big Trade for Fantasy Football!? 10 pts?

Question

I Get:

Tony Romo

Greg Jennings

Vince Young

He gets:

Ben Roethlisberger

Reggie Wayne

Brett Favre

Do you think this trade is fair? Why or why not? He offered me this offer except it was T.O. instead of Reggie Wayne. Best Answer gets 10 pts

Answer 1

look romo is good and jennings is a stud but i wouldn't take my chances with young

your giving t.o, farve and big ben that to much but farve will not do as good as last year

see if u can do this

Romo

Jennings

T.O

Favre

Romo will be better than farve

and jenning is a stud t.o will be better but jenning will get almost as much

Answer 2

Do the trade you get Tony Romo and sporting news picked the cowboys to win the super bowl.Brett Favre and the jets probly won't even make the playoffs with the pats in their division.Jennings isn't amazing but hes the packers number 1 guy.Reggie wayne is number 2 behind marvin harison at WR.If vince young perfects his throwing he can be a pro bowler.I'd take a chance on him because you already got romo.Plus brian Leftwich showed that he still has it in the preaseason so i think he might get a couple snaps in the regular season

Answer 3

Romo is a notch above Roeth but Wayne is several notches above Jennings.  I would do this if I have additional starting caliber WR's.  Jennings is a mid to low #2.

Young and Favre; edge to Favre but they are primarily bench players at this point no real impact.

Answer 4

I think it's really smart of you to get rid of those two QBs b/c there's no point of having both on your roster as long as you have a decent backup for the bye week, but I don't think it's wise give away T.O. or Reggie Wayne for the sake of getting Greg Jennings, who by the way will not have Favre throwing him bombs every game now. He's playing with Aaron Rodgers now so he might just end up frustrated like Randy Moss in Oakland b/c even though he's very talented (like Moss), playing in the wrong environment could lead to an unproductive year for him. So, depending on your backup situation, I would reject the offer and send him a counter offer for Tony Romo and another stud on his roster. I take it he must not have a stud receiver since he's eying both T.O. and Reggie Wayne. Keeping Wayne and Owens on the same team will do wonders by the way. Anyways, good luck. Hope that helped.