Big Trade!!!!?

Question

I get: Ryan Braun, Billy Wagner, Joba Chamberlain.

I give: Josh Hamilton, Jimmy Rollins, Joakim Soria.

My OF: Hamilton, Fukudome, Dye, Holliday, Bay.

My SS: Rollins, Reyes.

My P: Dempster, Volquez, Sherrill, Duchscherer, Lincecum, Soria, Haren, Burnett.

My 3B: Wright.

His OF: Braun, Ramirez, Sizemore, Vernon Wells, Markakis, Ludwick*, Sheffield.

His SS: Greene.

His P: Halladay, Oswalt, K-Rod, Wagner, Shields, Chamberlain, Beckett, Okajima **.

His 3B: Braun, Ramirez*.

*Player involved in another pending trade.

**Player involved in another pending trade, but being dropped.

I know the teams are stacked, it's only 6 in the league. If you want to know the other trade, then just say so. Thanks.

Answer 1

Wow!!!  Braun and Chamberlain!!! AND WAGNER!!!  Make the trade!!!  It'll probably be the best thing you ever did!!!

Answer 2

No definitely not. I would love to acquire me some Joba Chamberlain but you cannot do it at the price of Jimmy Rollins.

I don't think Hamilton will hold up but he has the stats right now.

Here's how I see this...

Rollins>Braun (Rollins hit the DL. He is going to be the better player from now on unless your desperate for RBis and you shouldn't be with Hamilton)

Soria=Wagner (both are doing great)

Hamilton>Chamberlain (always take the hitter over the pitcher)

You don't gain anything. Say no!

Answer 3

pull the accept button. you got a good deal