Big trade proposal! Johan, Verlander, Floyd for Zambrano, Beckett and Soria

Question

I was offered Zambrano, Beckett and Soria for Johan Santana, Gavin Floyd and Justin Verlander.

My staff if (minus Floyd, Johan and Verlander)

My staff is

Cliff Lee

Ricky Nolasco

Chris Carpenter

Liriano

Marcum

Scott Baker

Mike Pelfrey

George Sherrill

Troy Percival

Answer 1

I'd do it; you're getting another closer plus Verlander ain't that good.