Bought cologne on ebay/sealed box. Spray broken. Can I exchange at a local store?

Question

I figure since the store will just get a credit from the cologne people...it is just easier for me & I'm not profiting from it. It is an even exchange. Has anyone done this before? Your thoughts?

Answer 1

No.  It is not ethical to do this. /

Answer 2

Chances are 9 out of 10 you won't be able to exchange the cologne at a local store without a receipt from the store you're exchanging it at.  They want proof that you bought it at their store so they don't lose money.  Sorry.

Answer 3

No