Brandon roy or carmelo anthony?

Question

who do u think is better?

Answer 1

Brandon Roy is so much better, he gets more steals and I bet he plays more better on the defensive side. Carmelo only knows how to score, he also doesn't know how to lead a team. Roy is way better than garbage Carmelo.

Answer 2

melo for sure

Answer 3

carmelo

Answer 4

I'd go with brandon roy. Carmelo needs a life coach to get his act together.

Answer 5

I'd rather have Roy on my team.  I don't think any team with Carmelo as its star is ever going to win in the NBA and I don't think he has the makeup to play second fiddle to anyone.

Answer 6

melo is an offensive machine.  one of teh best ever on offense. cant say much for his defense.  still though, melo over roy easy.  dont know about that in a few years cuzy roy was last years ROY and he shows tons of upside as he as already been successful in the league, but roy has lots of catching up to do

Answer 7

Brandon Roy.

When you think about Melo, his game isn't very incomplete. Sure, he's a great jumpshooter and a great rebounder, but that's about it.

Roy is a better passer, better defender, and a better teammate. Plus Carmelo hasn't been able to take any of his teams out of the first round yet despite having plenty of talent around him.

Answer 8

well from last years success even though the blazers didnt make the playoffs I would say broy but most people are saying melo cuz they see him more. So i would say brandon roy: rookie of the year, second year all star, and now with jarryd bayless and Greg Oden coming in as support cast i say brandon roy will have lots of success in the future including this year.

Answer 9

melo

Answer 10

Melo hands down.

Carmelo is a proven player, with great scoring ability

Answer 11

brandon roy

peace....

Answer 12

Carmelo anthony hands down, lol. well at least for now.

Answer 13

Carmelo Anthony but maybe in a few years Brandon Roy will be better