Braylon Edwards and Rudi Johnson for Marques Colston and Marion Barber

Question

My team is the one with Braylon and Rudi. I like this trade though, whats your guys opinion. should i accept or reject it.

Answer 1

whoever made that trade to you is an idiot. take it. Rudi has questions surrounding him, he may be put in an RBBC situation, and Colston isnt much of a drop..hes pretty similar to Edwards

Answer 2

You have to accept it because Marion Barber is a Tier 1 running back and Colston is the biggest red zone scoring threat (next to moss).  Braylon Edwards is a Tier 1 wide reciever but Rudi Johnson is trash in my book.

Answer 3

take the trade. marion barber is way better then rudi johnson and marques colston is awesome. you would basically be replacing a great wr with another great wr and you would be getting an even better rb. its a score if you take the deal.

Answer 4

Personally, I would accept it. You give up a great WR, but a mediocre runningback. You receive a good WR, and a great runningback.

It's your choice though.

Answer 5

accept it You are down grading in the wide receiver column a little bit but upgrading big in the RB column.

Answer 6

Not enough information but giving up a top 10 RB and top tier receiver for a has been RB (Rudi Johnson) and top receiver is pathetic IMO. Basically you pretty much scewing the other team so I take it he is a newbie? How pathetic.  

Answer 7

score - sell sell sell