Breaking dawn controversy

Question

so i know that people are debating about why the book is bad and why its good.. will you guys post why its good or why its bad please??

Answer 1

Its bad because she didnt tie the ends up well enough so I feel like I need more about Bella's life as a vampire and the Volturi are still after her...its good because she ended up with everything going right with edward and nessie and jacob.

Answer 2

I was happily surprised by the unexpected story line but it has created a lot of controversy among fans. The first few chapters are pretty disturbing. There is a lot more adult content in Breaking Dawn than the other books and the characters seem a little, well, out of character.  

Answer 3

It's bad because it's the "cool" book to read, lol.