Brian Giles, Eric Hinske, or Casey Blake?

Question

I currently have Brian Giles on my roster. Hinske and Blake are in the free agents and i was wondering of i should keep Giles or go with Hinske or Blake.

Answer 1

I would keep Brian Giles. You know he's going to be there and play and he can hit for a decent average.

Answer 2

Hinske

Answer 3

go with Hinske. the Rays are surging right now. plus, he has 1B eligibility.

Answer 4

Giles will be traded before the end of the year. most likely to a contender. could help or hurt. Rays will turm to veterans down the stretch so hinske seems like a good bet

if you are not in the top 3 .. i dont think any of these guys help. pick up a guy with big upside that hasnt started rolling