Brian Westbrook for Marion Barber, should i take it?

Question

westbrook is injury prone, barber isnt proven

Answer 1

That is such a tough  question,however considering the last 2 yr. stats i would have to go with Westbrook as he can not only run but catches a lot of passes and has a nose for the end zone..Then again w/o julius jones in the back field its hard not to take Marion barber but remember dallas has soooo many other weapons so after pondering this for a bit i would lean more towards Westbrook...

Answer 2

I'm sorry to say but that would be a terrible trade, westbrook misses maybe one game of the season and he is the teams offense.  Barber is good but he might split with felix and dallas has a lot of weapons

Answer 3

I wouldn't do it considering that Westbrook was second in total yards from scrimmage last year.  But saying that Barber is unproven is incorrect - he is a proven TD machine.  Last year he had over 1200 yards rushing and receiving and 10 TDs while sharing carries with Julius Jones who is now gone.

Answer 4

I'd counter offer with another area you could upgrade.

For instance if he has J.Witten,and you have C.Cooley,then include them in your trade.(Barber+Witten for Westbrook+Cooley)

~G{}{}d Luck!~