Brisbane 03 vs Geelong 08 who would win if these teams went head to head?

Question

with Port I think your thinking about 04 when they won the GF

Answer 1

Brisbane,    to win 3 premierships in a row is a massive achievement, if geelong were to win 3 in a row, we'll look at the question again.

Answer 2

Brisbane by far. They were absoulutly increadable+unbeatable.

Wait, you couldn't compare them because the rules have changed a fair bit since then so..... duno.

Answer 3

Brisbane, I don't think Geelong are THAT good this year, sure they still win, but they don't often play 4 strong quarters, this year. I don't know what's happened in the space of 7 months, but they're not playing the good footy we got used to last year.

Geelong 07 vs Brisbane 03

Geelong

Answer 4

one of the toughest questions ever put on here, good one, very hard to answer, both have gun midfields, where most games are won, from the engine room, decent forward set ups, very good backlines, i really couldn't split them being neutral, it'd be one h**l of a game to see. one tiny thing that sways me is Brisbane won 3, geelong, so far have 1, so if i was made to pick a winner, i'd say Brisbane, just.

Answer 5

Geelong '07 would win easily.  In fact you could put Port AND Lions on the ground that day and Geelong would win.

'08.  Cats aren't playing so well yet.  Missing a few good players (Egan in particular) but they seem cocky.  The 03 Lions would give them a good run.

Answer 6

geelong i think

brisbane were very good, but i seem to remember port adelaide being top of the ladder most of the time, not sure though

geelong, im assuming, will spend most if not all of this year on top

that being said, brisbane did win 3 cups in a row, so if geelong can do then we can truly compare them

Answer 7

I'd have to say Brisbane but it would be close they had some great players and geelong are finally starting to click it's taken them long enough....collingwood,port and sydney suck

Answer 8

Geelong i guess. i dont really remember brisbane in 2003.

Answer 9

Geelong.

The Liars wouldn't last five minutes with today's testing methods!

Answer 10

Brisbane

Answer 11

Brisbane by 29 points

They had three years at the top by then and a gun midfield,Lynch and Brown up foreward, Voss Acker and other winners all over the ground

Geelong in 08 still unbeaten but not near there 07 form