Can I have someone's honest opinion?

Question

Is this really any good? I have mixed emotions personally.

Its "In My Bed" by Amy Winehouse

Here's the original by Amy for anyone unfamiliar with the song.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jdW27IBEOZM

Here's the other one:

http://www.zshare.net/audio/17623477712ad8d5/

Thanks! Remember I appreciate honesty before being nice to someone's feelings.

Answer 1

I'm not the biggest Amy Whinehouse fan, but it's not too bad of a song, you're version I won't lie to you because that's not what you asked for.

Your version is a little shaky, but not too bad. i think you should work on it a little and try singing maybe Joss Stone or maybe, can you sing a bit more rough and edgy music, or rockin' music, I'd be interested in maybe hearing that.

But all in all, yours is not to bad, just a little shaky.  

Answer 2

I LOVE THIS SONG!

AMY IS THE BEST SINGER/SONGWRITER EVER!

EVERY SONG BY HER IS BRILLIANT