Can India be more successful if it adopts communism?

Question

I think our Indian people don't deserve democracy.

What do you thi

Answer 1

COMMUNISM: Communism is a socioeconomic structure that promotes the establishment of a classless, stateless society based on common ownership of the means of production

IF COMMUNISM COMES TO BE THE STATE OF INDIA, I GUESS NO INDIANS WILL BE ABLE TO DO A SIMPLE BUSSINESS ALSO.

it will also lead to revolts around the society and the real benefactors of communism will be BURGLARS AND THIEVES.When communism starts there will be nobody to ask or question the ppl who r doing wrong and each one will take the power in their hands and even it will be more worse problem in india than wat its facing now.i guess there r even some communist parties in india which never saw power its because it will become a arrogant rule.Imagine a sudden hike in petrol price to 100 rsper litre and nobody should question them and its too arrogant.DON'T FORGET COMMUNISM GAVE BIRTH TO MANY CIVIL WARS AND WARS GLOBALLY ,i feel communists and communism where a lot behind hitler and his moto.

If general ppl will not fear of doing crime then imagine how INDIA will be after communism.COMMUNISM IS A VIEW WHICH CREATES MANY HEROS WHO THINK THEY R HEROS OF GOOD DEED BUT ACTUALLY THEY DO BAD FOR THE SOCIETY.Communism starts to make a man think so selfishly that how india gave its power to english long ago.

DEMERITS OF COMMUNISM:

1. lack of education

2. slavery being established again

3. own laws and own motto's according to the leader's and ppl may suffer

4. thefts and killing will increase

5. economy of a communist country will go down gradually

so its better we have a community where illegal things r done in a legal way with little fear under the name of democracy, rather than ppl start to do things directly illegaly without any fear under the name of communism.

Answer 2

India is a socialist country.

Answer 3

No, even though that looks like the answer you don't want to hear. I think you should are doing a litle mixing between politics and economics here, but let me argue that democratic capitalism is the best path for India.

First, when you say communism, I assume you mean the ideal enviosned by Marx, not Maosit or Stalinist versions. There is great appeal to this, but as James Madison says, "If men were angels, we wouldn't need government." Communism assumes people will gladly work for others who do not. They won't. Men, and women are not angels indeed, as much as we would like them to be. Capitalism harnesses their passions and greed for public good, communism ignores them or pretends they don't exist.

This idealist socialism influenced early Indian leaders who strived for shared wealth and paternalistic socialism. Unfortunately, Indians who were poor remained so, and the caste system is only partly to blame. India was very socialist indeed, and had much government interference of markets.

Only recently has India,like China, started to reform their systems. In both countries there is likely to be a great deal of poverty, political upheaval, and economic uncertainty, but thats the way the world is. If your nation continues to adopt capitalism poverty will exist, but even the poorest of standards of living will be higher than they were before. Their will be more wealth, but it will not be equitable. So, economically, Indians must choose to be equitably poor, or to be unevenly rich.

You might think Indians don't deserve democracy, but what do they think about it?