Can Ray Emery beat Zdeno Chara in a fight?

Question

Could a goaltender take on a defensemen? Zdeno Chara a 6 foot 9 monster defensemen, and one of the best fighters in the NHL. Against a 5 foot 11 goalie, Ray Emery, the best goalie fighter ever in the NHL. Who would come out victorious, Emery the goalie, or Chara the defensemen?

Answer 1

I don't know, but I'd enjoy it if he did.  I was at a game once where 6-9 Chara started a fight with 5-7 Brian Gionta.  (He's listed as 5-8, but who's kidding who.) And the fight was a standstill until the refs broke it up.

Oh yeah, the Devils won, and I think Gionta may have gotten an assist on a defense that included Chara, so if you count moral victories, Gionta was 4-0 that day.  (Win, assist, on Chara, didn't lose to Chara in a fight.  If a goal, an assist and winning a fight is a "Gordie Howe hat trick," then what I described can be called a "Gionta grand slam.")

Answer 2

I'm gonna have to choose Chara on this one. He's got such a long reach its hard for guys to even get close to him.

Answer 3

Ray Emery is a piece of s***! He will never play hockey for the Ottawa Senators again and I LOVE IT that way! Ray Emery isn't a good teammate and no one wants a guy who will distract their team like Ray Emery does!

Answer 4

Emery is not the best goailie fighter ever seen Roy was much better. Chara would clean him up

Answer 5

h**l no

Answer 6

Chara

Just ask David Koci

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q3_ghTTQe...

or Bryan McCabe

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LMWLFca67...

Answer 7

i would say chara just because of his size. if it was anyone else smaller than chara, then emery could win. While im talking about emery, i would just like to say that im not a sens fan or an emery fan but it wasnt his fault the sens lost. he acted the same way he did last year when they lost to the ducks exept in one year they made it to the finals and the other one they didnt.

i hope that helps and it was a good question. i would like to see those to fight one day. :)

Answer 8

he cant even beat peters in a fight. i would say its a good fight at best, a beatdown at worse when you initiate with chara.

a beast with a reach

Answer 9

Emery is Chara's best ho!

Answer 10

maybe if Chara was tied up

Answer 11

Only if he punched him in the nuts.

Answer 12

The big tough guy, Chara

Answer 13

Further proof that hockey fans are a bloodthirsty lot. Hockey appeals to the base of society.

Answer 14

emery couldnt beat peters, how is he gonna beat chara?

Answer 15

Emery acts like hes tough but hes got issues.

Answer 16

no way

Answer 17

CME's avatar could take Emery. There's a reason his amature boxing "career" didn't pan out.