Can a prophet be a psycho?

Question

Mirza Ghulam Qadyani wrote: “I suffer from hypochondria” (Al Hakam, Oct. 31, 1961)

Abu Ali Sina (Avicenna) has clarified in his book ‘Al Qanun’:

“Hypochondria is a disease in which imagination and thoughts change continuously due to fear and disturbance. The very core of the brain becomes unsociable and savage and the patient grows disorderly due to the accumulated intensity of this disease.”

Now, this hypochondria is a form of melancholia. Dr. Adler gives a very accurate description of it:

"Melancholia is like a long continued rage and reproach against others, though for the purpose of gaining care, sympathy and support, the patient seems only to be dejected about his own guilt. A melanchoilac's first memory is generally something like this: 'I remember I wanted to lie on the couch, but my brother was lying there. I cried so much that he had to leave."

Allama Burhannudin declares: “Hypochondria is a disease in which the natural faculty of conception and perception changes to the unnatural until a stage is reached when the patient believes he is omniscient. Some of the patients think they r angels”

So does this explain why he claimed that he changed into Mary, conceived, and gave birth to Isa? And then became Isa himself? And his other wild fantasies about God?

Answer 1

Its pretty much a guarantee that anyone who claims to be a prophet is a psycho, or at least someone who has some sort of mental problem.  

Answer 2

Thats a very good question lets see If any Ahmadis Answer this Question.

Which I highly doubt

Answer 3

Well put dear I think they were all crazy on acid or other hallucogenics.

Answer 4

I am not a doctor but I do know driving cars sounded crazy in 1806.

Answer 5

Mirza Ghulam Qadyani isn't a prophet. when u read abt history u have to clarify if it is true or not n then spread the message.

prophets are not psychos ( nauzubillah)!!!!!!

Answer 6

ITS ALL WRONG MIRZA GHULAM NOT A PROPHET

NO PROOF

HE CAN BE A PSYCHO CAUSE HES NOT A PROPHET

Answer 7

jesus was 1 crazy m**o

Answer 8

NO, BUT SUNNIS ARE !

Answer 9

Amazing that no one has the courage to comply with my simple request.  Is this the sign of a truthful questioner?

My expectation to answer questions regarding quotes of Hazrat Ahmad (as) is evidence you've read the book yourself, either in the original language or a translation done by the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat.

Otherwise it is a waste of your time and my time and those of this forum especially. I've answered every question in the past regarding quotes, and true to what I predicted, all you do is find new quotes from new anti ahmadi websites. More than once now people have posted quotes that don't even exist and are just made up. Is this what a Muslim does?

This puts you, sadly, in the same category of those who assault Islam with websites like faithfreedom.org etc. I do not associate with such people who assault Islam with those websites, and thus it does not make sense Islamically to associate with those who assault the Messiah and Mahdi sent by Allah with those type of websites.

If you have read the book, show me by posting at least 1 page from before the quote in question, the quote in question, and 1 page after the quote in question. Then I will gladly answer it, you have my word in writing.

I will gladly answer any questions from the Qur'an and Hadeeth as I can only hope you actually have read those on your own.

Allah bless you sister.

love for all, hatred for none

Answer 10

V, good question

@ 1qfac.... What u said is a common Qadyani's practice,

"One page b4 and after''

its not possible for muslims to carry your all books Filled with filth ,all the time , You know that, that's why u get exit with this ,

"One page b4 and after "

When any non muslim says any thing about quran ,our Ulma defend that

Why cant you post one page b4 & after  

and show where we quoted Mirza QAdyani ,out of context.

As u r qadyani u must have his books  & studied  them.

And i told you many times i have personally studied your books (origional ) and talked to your so called scholars ,who r so ignorant that they start cursing who asks a question,when they get trapped.

This is my first hand experience ,Sorry to bring the fact on the tabble.I do not want to hurt you ,I just wana make u understand that how wrong u r .

Correct your self b4 the time is over for the paper.

Answer 11

Mirza Ghulam Qadiani did not have any scruples at using profanities to try to ridicule, intimidate, or threaten people who did not accept his false claim to prophethood.  Here are a few examples of his writings:

    "My enemies are dirty swine and their women are more wretched than b*****s."

          (Roohany Khazaen, Vol. 14, P. 53; Najmul Huda, P. 10, 53)

    "All Muslims regard my books with reverence and care and benefit from their sublime thoughts except those who are the offspring of prostitutes (b******s); God has put a seal upon their hearts and they do not accept me."

          (Roohany Khazaen, Vol. 5, Page 547-548; Mirat-o-Kamalat-i-Islam, P. 547;

          Aeena-e-Kamalat Islam, P.547-548)

          [Mirza Ghulam translated this Arabic word as "b*****d" in

           Roohany Khazaen Vol. 11, P. 282)

    "The one who has no belief in our ultimate victory is fond of becoming b*****d and he is bound to be product of fornication."

          (Roohany Kazaen, Vol. 9, P. 31; Anwar ul Islam, P. 30)

    "Are they prepared to swear?  No, they'll never do so because they are liars and are derooting the corpse of falsehood like dogs."

          (Supplement to Anjam-e-Atham, P. 25; Roohany Khazaen, Vol. 11, P. 309)

    His eulogy about Maulvi Saadullah Ludhianwi was:

        "I look a sinful man among debauched who is more scoundrel and an execrated being like Satan...  He who is called Saadullah by the ignorant is slanderer, wicked and a falsifier...  You injured me, b*****d.  I won't be truthful if you won't have a disgraceful death."      

        (Haqiqat-ul Wahi, P. 14-15; Roohany Khazaen, Vol. 22, P. 734-735)

    "If Abdullah Athum is saved from death (as per Mirza's prophecy) and if all the world say the Christian was correct, then the b*****d will not follow the right path."

          (Roohany Khazaen, Vol. 9, P. 32)

    "Abdul Haq is not content with our victories.  He is itching to become a b*****d."

           (Anwar-ul-Islam, P. 30)

    "There is nothing more foul than a pig in the world.  But the ulema who oppose me are more foul than pigs."

          (Anjam-i-Atham, P. 21)

    "You have inflicted pain on me with your foulness.  You are not truthful.  I pray that you die in shame, you son of a harlot."

         (Anjam-i-Atham, P. 288)

    "This b*****d of a doctor does not thread the straight path."

          (Anwar-ul-Islam, P. 30)

    He called Shaikhul Islam Saanaullah of Amristar:

       "O, the son of wind, o traitor..."

          (Ijaz-i-Ahmadi, P. 43/77)

The puzzling thing is that he himself wrote:

    "I have never abused anyone."

          (Moahiburahman, P. 18)

    "He is worst who is abusive, his heart is as filthy as Latrine."

          (Sar-e-Sumain, P. 74)

    "Abuses and rebukes are not the acts of  a believer and a believer can not be a curser."

         (Azalat-ul-Auham, P. 66)

Is this how a Prophet or even a rightly guided individual would speak?

Edit:

theq1factor:-Look at his amazing excuse for not answering the question!!!

When faithfreedom and answeringIslam attacks Islam,

even a Muslim child defends and answers them,

on the contrary you with all your knowledge of studying Qadyanism for 10 years,could not even touch the topic posed by the asker and myself,

If i were you,

I would be ashamed to death

May Allah guide U

Answer 12

A Prophet chosen by Allah cannot be a psycho. Truly ghulam ahmed was a common man and a psycho and called himself a prophet which Prophet (saww) warned us 1400 yrs ago about the trolls impersonating him in the future and ghulam ahmed was one of them. Therefore whatever he (ghulam ahmed) said in his books or verbally is BS.

Answer 13

Yes. Anyone who claims that they are some sort of prophet is probably snorting a lot of coke.

So yes they are not reliable, trustworthy sources of information and as such should maybe be institutionalized before someone gets hurt.

Goofnuts!

Answer 14

i think its extremely wrong to use the term "psycho" when refering to any of God's messengers. and in short, the answer is obviously NO.

Allah chose them from all of al nas to bring His message or books, and astaghfirAllah i just dont think that anyone can say that Allah would chose someone with a mental illness...... its true that Muhammas saws thought at first when he was visited by Jibreel that he was going crazy, but later Khadijah (ra) helped him understand that he was indeed a messenger of God. salaam.