Can you rate my 2008 fantasy baseball draft?

Question

This is strictly my draft day picks. I have made moves since. For the most part, I consider my draft otherworldly in a 10-man h2h (I hate h2h baseball) league. What you think?

1. (1) Álex Rodríguez 3B

2. (20) Jake Peavy SP

3. (21) Brandon Phillips 2B

4. (40) Brandon Webb SP

5. (41) Nick Markakis OF

6. (60) Carlos Peña 1B

7. (61) Brian McCann C

8. (80) Miguel Tejada SS

9. (81) Brad Hawpe OF

10. (100) Bobby Jenks RP

11. (101) Trevor Hoffman RP

12. (120) Juan Pierre OF

13. (121) Adrián Béltre 3B

14. (140) Brad Penny SP

15. (141) Josh Hamilton OF

16. (160) Dustin McGowan SP

17. (161) Orlando Hudson 2B

18. (180) Jarrod Saltalamacchia C,1B

19. (181) Yunel Escobar 2B,3B,SS

20. (200) Kerry Wood RP

21. (201) Andrew Miller SP

Answer 1

How did you manage to get Josh Hamilton at 141?!? If this is a mid-season league, I give you a 10/10 for that alone.

Answer 2

I am assuming this draft took place before the start of the season. But here are my thoughts on a couple of picks that really stand out:

Brandon Webb- getting Webb where you did at 40th overall has turned out to be a great pick.

Markakis- you drafted too high for a player with such limited experience in the bigs. He will be good, but most likely won't live up to where you drafted him.

Pena- this has turned out to be a terrible pick for you. Pena has struggled with his average and has hit the DL.

McCann- very good pick. He has been the best catcher in fantasy so far this season.

Brad Hawpe- terrible pick. He was solid last year, but nothing great. He has struggled tremendously so far.

Trevor Hoffman- bad pick. Hoffman since the 2nd half of last season has been struggling and his age is really starting to show. Plus, the Padres lineup doesn't help his value.

Kerry Wood- Very good pick at 200. He has solidified his position as closer and has been very solid thus far.

Josh Hamilton- This was by far your best pick. Hamilton's talent has been on full display this season and he has been the best player in fantasy thus far.